Skip to main content

ACLU Challenges Short Appeal Window for Migrants Under Wartime Act

by LC Staff Writer | Apr 29, 2025
A border enforcement officer monitors a group of migrants lined up behind a fence in a detention facility.
Photo Source: US Customs and Border Protection via aclu.org

Migrants targeted for removal from the United States under the controversial Alien Enemies Act now have approximately 12 hours to decide whether to contest their deportation, according to recently unsealed court documents. The brief timeframe, disclosed on Thursday, has intensified legal challenges, with advocates arguing it violates the Supreme Court’s directive requiring a "reasonable" period for appeals.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), representing affected migrants, condemned the government's approach, highlighting the inadequacy of the 12-hour window. Lee Gelernt, an attorney with the ACLU, described the situation as a "dramatic turn," emphasizing that detainees receive insufficient guidance on their rights and lack adequate time to consult attorneys.

Under the seldom-used wartime statute, Venezuelans accused of belonging to the criminal organization Tren de Aragua have been deported to El Salvador’s notorious CECOT prison. According to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), detainees must state their intention to challenge removal within 12 hours after receiving a form outlining their legal rights. Subsequently, migrants have only 24 hours to file relevant court documents.

Critically, the government-issued form detailing these rights is provided solely in English, though ICE claims detainees have it read aloud in their native languages. The form informs individuals of their right to a phone call but fails to clearly state the possibility of contesting their removal under the Alien Enemies Act. Initially, government officials attempted to seal this document, asserting it contained sensitive law enforcement information, but a federal judge mandated its public release.

The ACLU argues the imposed timeframe starkly contrasts historical precedent. During World War II, the Alien Enemies Act was used against suspected Nazis, who then received 30 days to challenge their removal. Earlier this week, a Colorado federal judge mandated a minimum 21-day notice period, ruling against the Trump administration’s significantly shorter deadlines. The government quickly appealed, asserting that the expedited timelines still provide constitutional due process.

Justice Department attorney Tim Ramnitz contended in court filings that the provided notice grants migrants a reasonable chance to indicate their intent to contest deportation, file a habeas corpus petition, and access telephones. ICE officials also stated detainees are typically held for several days prior to removal, implying they have more opportunity to seek legal recourse than the initial 12-hour window suggests.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

LC Staff Writer
Law Commentary’s Staff Writers are dedicated legal professionals and journalists who excel at making complex legal topics accessible and relatable. They are committed to providing clear, accurate commentary that helps readers understand the impact of legal news on their daily lives.

Related Articles

ICE officer wearing a vest labeled “POLICE ICE” stands outside barred detention facility cells.

Federal Appeals Court Rules ICE Can Detain Immigrants Without Bond Hearings

A federal appeals court ruled 10-7 Friday, October 23, 2026, that ICE can detain certain immigrants throughout their deportation proceedings without granting them bond hearings, overturning an earlier decision requiring hearings within 90 days and allowing detention to continue even after prolonged confinement.The full Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals... Read More about Federal Appeals Court Rules ICE Can Detain Immigrants Without Bond Hearings

Protesters hold a “Release Mahmoud Khalil” sign featuring his portrait outside Columbia University.

Mahmoud Khalil Asks Supreme Court to Overturn Ruling That Could Put Him Back in ICE Custody

Mahmoud Khalil, the former Columbia University graduate student who spent 104 days in immigration detention over his pro-Palestinian activism, asked the U.S. Supreme Court on October 19, 2026, to overturn a ruling that could send him back into ICE custody as the Trump administration pursues his deportation.Khalil, a lawful permanent... Read More about Mahmoud Khalil Asks Supreme Court to Overturn Ruling That Could Put Him Back in ICE Custody

The U.S. Supreme Court building viewed from below against a partly cloudy sky.

Supreme Court Clears Trump to Resume Third-Country Deportations as Justices Take Up Legal Fight

The Supreme Court on Tuesday cleared the Trump administration to resume deporting migrants to countries other than their own while the justices prepare to decide whether the policy violates federal law and constitutional due process protections.The unsigned September 29 order puts on hold a federal court judgment that required migrants... Read More about Supreme Court Clears Trump to Resume Third-Country Deportations as Justices Take Up Legal Fight

U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota building in Minneapolis.

DOJ Uses Secretive “Alien Terrorist Removal Court” for the First Time

The Justice Department has carried out the first deportation ordered through a little-known federal court created three decades ago to remove noncitizens accused of terrorism using procedures that permit the government to rely on classified evidence.Nazira Haji Zada, a 47-year-old Afghan national and lawful permanent resident who had been living... Read More about DOJ Uses Secretive “Alien Terrorist Removal Court” for the First Time

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem testifies during a Senate hearing.

Habeas Corpus in Spotlight After Administration Suggests Possible Suspension

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem sparked controversy this week by mischaracterizing the fundamental legal right of habeas corpus during a Senate hearing, incorrectly asserting it was a presidential authority to deport immigrants. Habeas corpus, a cornerstone of the U.S. legal system, is a constitutional protection against unlawful detention. It allows... Read More about Habeas Corpus in Spotlight After Administration Suggests Possible Suspension

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter