Skip to main content

California Homeowners Say Insurance Companies Colluded To Limit Coverage in Wildfire Prone Areas

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Apr 28, 2025
Firefighters watch as a helicopter drops water on a wildfire burning on a hillside.
Photo Source: AP Photo/John Locher via AP News

Two new lawsuits filed in Los Angeles accuse major home insurance providers in the state of colluding to limit the coverage they offer homeowners in regions of California where there is an elevated risk of wildfires. As a result, this has forced homeowners to turn to the state's FAIR Plan, an insurance plan with high premiums and basic coverage.

One of the lawsuits was brought forward by a group of homeowners who lost their homes in this year's wildfires. The other lawsuit represents homeowners who received coverage through the California FAIR (Fair Access to Insurance Requirements) Plan after January 2023.

The FAIR Plan is designed as a temporary insurance policy program that homeowners who are at high risk can turn to if they are unable to get coverage for their homes. Major insurance providers pay into this program, and this pool of funds is used to help individuals who are covered under the FAIR Plan.

There are obvious drawbacks, however. For example, the plan has high premiums and offers homeowners only basic coverage. Coverage is also capped at $3 million. Despite being a temporary option, now more than ever, residents in the state are relying on it as their only form of coverage.

In 2020, the number of home policies under the program more than doubled. Today, those numbers have nearly quadrupled. There are over 555,000 policies under this program to date.

Among the insurance companies named in the lawsuit were State Farm and 20 other companies. Together, these companies control over 75% of the insurance market in the state. Their collusion was a violation of the state’s antitrust and Unfair CompetitionUnfair competition is a broad area of law addressing deceptive, misleading, or wrongful business practices that harm competitors, consumers, or another party's commercial identity.Read more → laws, the complaints alleged.

The lawsuits explain that starting in 2023, the insurance companies "suddenly and simultaneously" came together to drop current policyholders who lived in fire prone areas.

Among these neighborhoods were residents in Pacific Palisades and Altadena. Both these communities were devastated by the January wildfires that destroyed 17,000 residential and commercial buildings. Along with dropping existing customers, the insurance companies stopped writing new policies for residents who live in these areas.

Both lawsuits argue that after homeowners were dropped and were forced to turn to the FAIR Plan, they suffered significant losses because they found themselves underinsured. According to recent data from Realtor.com, the median listing home price of a house in the Pacific Palisades was roughly $6.2 million, nearly double the coverage offered under the FAIR Plan.

By forcing families into this state home insurance option, residents were left with limited options when it came to being able to afford rebuilding, as many homeowners say they were left uninsured and vulnerable when disaster did strike.

Michael J. Bidart is the attorney representing the homeowners in one of the lawsuits. He shares, "Insurance is a product that homeowners hope never to need, but rely on for peace of mind in normal times and for critical help rebuilding after a catastrophe." His statement representing his clients goes on, "The complaints allege that, by colluding to push plaintiffs and so many like them to the FAIR Plan, the defendants have reaped the benefits of high premiums while depriving homeowners of coverage that they were ready, willing, and able to purchase to ensure that they could recover after a disaster like January's wildfires."

As wildfires throughout the state continue to be an unpredictable and difficult to manage natural disaster, homeowners and businesses have remained uncertain about their future in the state.

In the background, the state is continuing to struggle with helping residents find affordable home insurance coverage. With few insurance companies to choose from, some residents are seeing inflated home insurance coverage rates, while others are struggling to find a private company that will provide them coverage in the first place.

While the state Department of Insurance is not involved in the lawsuits, they have issued a statement that explained in part, "Californians deserve a system that works — one where decisions are made openly, rates reflect real risk, and no one is left without options."

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Dome of the California State Capitol rising against a clear blue sky with flags flying from flagpoles around the structure.

California Wildfire Liability Bill Dies After Lawmakers Reject Newsom Limits on Victim Payouts

California lawmakers ended the legislative session Tuesday without voting on a major wildfire liability bill after rejecting Gov. Gavin Newsom’s push to reduce what electric utilities could owe wildfire victims, insurers and local governments when their equipment sparks catastrophic fires.The Assembly declined to take up Senate Bill 492 on Sept.... Read More about California Wildfire Liability Bill Dies After Lawmakers Reject Newsom Limits on Victim Payouts

State Farm sign in front of a modern office building, with leafless trees and a trimmed hedge in the foreground.

State Farm Faces Bid to Unseal Records, Depose CEO in Oklahoma Roof Claim Lawsuit

An Oklahoma couple suing State Farm over a denied roof damage claim is asking a Comanche County judge to make internal company records public and require the insurer’s chief executive to answer questions under oath, arguing the evidence could support allegations that company policies influenced how their loss was handled.Comanche... Read More about State Farm Faces Bid to Unseal Records, Depose CEO in Oklahoma Roof Claim Lawsuit

Row of mobile homes with porches in a residential area.

Illinois Mobile Homeowners Claim Mobile Home Companies Conspired in Price Fixing Scheme

A group of corporate managers for mobile home communities along with a mobile home market data provider are the target of a new lawsuit that was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois Eastern Division. The lawsuit accuses the defendants of conspiring to influence rental... Read More about Illinois Mobile Homeowners Claim Mobile Home Companies Conspired in Price Fixing Scheme

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter