Skip to main content

Former Sen. Kyrsten Sinema Details Affair With Married Bodyguard in ‘Alienation of Affection’ Lawsuit

by Bridget Luckey | Aug 17, 2026
Kyrsten Sinema speaks at a podium on a stage, wearing glasses and a black and red sleeveless outfit.
Photo Source: David Herring/Shutterstock.com

Former U.S. Sen. Kyrsten Sinema has given sworn testimony detailing her sexual relationship with Matthew Ammel, a former member of her security detail, as she asks a federal judge to dismiss a North Carolina lawsuit accusing her of helping break up his marriage.

Heather Ammel, Matthew Ammel’s ex-wife, sued Sinema under North Carolina law, claiming the former Arizona senator knowingly interfered in the couple’s 14-year marriage and caused the loss of her husband’s affection. Sinema has acknowledged the romantic and sexual relationship but argues that the dispute does not belong in a North Carolina court because the conduct at issue occurred elsewhere.

Matthew Ammel began working as part of Sinema’s security operation in 2022. Their relationship later became romantic while Sinema was still serving in the U.S. Senate, according to court filings and her sworn testimony.

Heather Ammel claims Sinema’s involvement with her husband began before the marriage ended and included romantic communications, gifts, and private travel. The complaint states that love and affection still existed in the marriage before Sinema’s alleged interference. The couple separated in November 2024, and their divorce was finalized in March 2026.

During a July 31 deposition, Sinema testified that her physical relationship with Matthew Ammel began around Memorial Day weekend in 2024 in California. She described later sexual encounters in New York, Washington, Colorado, and Arizona. Sinema also testified that she learned in December 2023 that Ammel was married and had three children.

The lawsuit relies on alienation of affection, a civil claim that remains available under North Carolina law when a third party is alleged to have intentionally interfered with a marriage. The claim looks at the existence of genuine love and affection between the spouses, the loss of that relationship, and the role the outside person’s wrongful conduct played in causing it.

North Carolina courts can consider several factors when assessing the alleged interference. Evidence that the outside person knew about the marriage can also bear on malicious conduct, an element Heather Ammel raises by alleging that Sinema continued the relationship after learning Matthew Ammel was married.

State law limits actionable conduct to the period before spouses physically separate with the intent to remain apart. Heather and Matthew Ammel separated in November 2024, making the timing of Sinema’s alleged involvement and the condition of the marriage before that date part of the underlying dispute.

Heather Ammel filed the lawsuit in Moore County Superior Court on Sept. 30, 2025. Sinema later moved the case to the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina after Ammel confirmed that she is seeking more than $75,000 in damages. The complaint seeks damages for alienation of affection as well as punitive damages.

Sinema is now asking the federal court to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction. She lives in Arizona and argues that her ties to North Carolina are too limited for the state to exercise authority over her in a dispute involving a relationship that she says took place elsewhere.

Personal jurisdiction is governed in part by constitutional due process, which requires a meaningful connection between the person being sued, the state where the case was filed, and the dispute itself. Sinema argues that connection is missing because the encounters described in her testimony occurred in California, New York, Washington, Colorado, and Arizona.

Heather Ammel has opposed dismissal. U.S. District Judge David A. Bragdon allowed limited discovery focused on Sinema’s connections to North Carolina, leading to the July depositions of Sinema and the Ammels.

The testimony gave the court a more detailed record of when the relationship began, where the encounters occurred, and what each side says about the condition of the Ammels’ marriage. Those facts now form part of the record Bragdon will consider in Sinema’s bid to dismiss the case on jurisdictional grounds.

Bragdon is scheduled to hold an evidentiary hearing on Sinema’s Motion to DismissA request asking a court to end all or part of a lawsuit because the claim is legally insufficient or another threshold defect prevents it from proceeding.Read more → on Aug. 19 in the Middle District of North Carolina.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Get more Law Commentary in Google's Top Stories.

Bridget Luckey
Bridget studied Communications and Marketing at California State University, Long Beach. She also has experience in the live music events industry, which has allowed her to travel to festivals around the world. During this period, she acquired valuable expertise in branding, marketing, event planning, and public relations.

Related Articles

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang holds a microphone and smiles against a bright green backdrop.

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Sued Over Alleged Affair With Suspected Chinese Spy

A shareholder has filed a proposed class action against Nvidia and its CEO, Jensen Huang, accusing them of concealing Huang's alleged affair with a suspected Chinese spy and misleading investors about national security risks that could threaten the chipmaker's business and reputation.The proposed class action, filed November 9, 2026, in... Read More about Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Sued Over Alleged Affair With Suspected Chinese Spy

Leon Black, wearing sunglasses and a dark suit, appears beside Rep. Robert Garcia, who gestures while wearing a dark suit outdoors.

Billionaire Leon Black Sues Rep. Robert Garcia for $7.25M Over Epstein Claims

Billionaire investor Leon Black has sued Rep. Robert Garcia for $7.25 million, accusing the California Democrat of defaming him by publicly linking him to Jeffrey Epstein's sex trafficking crimes during television interviews.Filed November 4, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, the complaint seeks... Read More about Billionaire Leon Black Sues Rep. Robert Garcia for $7.25M Over Epstein Claims

Lindsey Graham speaks at a lectern during a public event.

Late Sen. Lindsey Graham Accused of Paying Male Escorts for Sex, Including Alleged 17-Year-Old

Three men have accused the late Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham of paying them for sex in a new documentary, including one who claims he was 17 when the South Carolina lawmaker paid him $120 for a sexual encounter in Arizona in 2001.The CLOSETocracy, released Thursday, October 22, 2026, by Swamp... Read More about Late Sen. Lindsey Graham Accused of Paying Male Escorts for Sex, Including Alleged 17-Year-Old

Eric Swalwell speaks into a microphone while raising one hand during an indoor event.

FBI Raids Billionaire Donor's Mansion in Eric Swalwell Sex Probe

FBI agents raided the Beverly Hills mansion of billionaire political donor Stephen Cloobeck on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, seeking electronic devices and records related to prostitution as part of a federal criminal investigation into former Congressman Eric Swalwell. The search follows allegations of sexual assault and other misconduct that drove... Read More about FBI Raids Billionaire Donor's Mansion in Eric Swalwell Sex Probe

Howard Stern poses wearing sunglasses and a black jacket at a public event.

Howard Stern Pulled Back Into Court Fight as Ex-Assistant Appeals NDA Lawsuit Dismissal

Howard Stern’s former executive assistant is trying to revive her lawsuit against the radio host and his wife after a New York judge dismissed her challenge to disputed confidentiality agreements earlier this year.Leslie Kuhn has appealed the July 29, 2026, ruling that threw out her case against Howard Stern, Beth... Read More about Howard Stern Pulled Back Into Court Fight as Ex-Assistant Appeals NDA Lawsuit Dismissal

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter