Skip to main content

Instacart Agrees to $60 Million FTC Settlement Over Delivery Fees, Refunds, and Subscription Practices

by Alexandra Agraz | Dec 29, 2025
Instacart logo on a dark green sign with blurred produce in the background
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Instacart has agreed to pay $60 million and change how it presents delivery fees, refunds, and subscription enrollments under a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission, according to federal court records. The agreement would impose long-term rules on how the company presents pricing information and subscription terms.

The settlement resolves a consumer protection case brought by the FTC against Maplebear Inc., which operates the grocery delivery platform. Federal regulators alleged that Instacart used marketing practices that misled consumers about delivery costs, refund availability, and paid subscription terms.

Under the agreement, Instacart would be barred from misrepresenting the total cost consumers pay for delivery orders. The order requires the company to disclose all fees that affect the total price before consumers complete a transaction or provide payment information, a requirement intended to ensure users understand the full cost of an order before deciding whether to proceed.

The settlement also addresses how Instacart advertised refunds. Regulators alleged that the company promoted a “100 percent satisfaction guarantee” while often limiting remedies to credits or partial refunds rather than returning money to the original payment method. The agreement prohibits advertising refunds in ways that could mislead consumers and requires clearer disclosure of any limits or conditions tied to refunds.

In addition, the order governs changes to Instacart’s customer reporting tools. According to the FTC, consumers seeking help with missing or delayed orders were frequently directed toward credits, while refund options were less visible within the platform. The settlement requires that refund information be presented clearly so consumers can understand the options available to them.

A significant portion of the settlement focuses on Instacart+, the company’s paid subscription service. The FTC alleged that Instacart enrolled consumers into annual memberships through free trial offers that automatically converted into paid plans unless canceled. Under the stipulated order, Instacart must disclose renewal terms, recurring charges, and refund limitations before enrolling users and must obtain express affirmative consent, meaning a clear agreement from the consumer, before billing begins.

The agency alleged that some consumers did not realize they had been charged for a subscription until charges appeared on their payment statements. Court filings reference consumer complaints and internal research indicating that some users were unaware that a trial would renew into a $99 annual membership and that canceling the service did not necessarily result in a refund once billing began.

The legal claims resolved by the settlement were brought under Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act, which prohibits unfair or deceptive acts in commerce, including misleading advertising or leaving out information that would matter to a reasonable consumer. The FTC also relied on the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, known as ROSCA, which regulates online sales using negative option features where a consumer can be charged automatically unless they cancel.

Negative option features are common in everyday transactions, including free trials, streaming services, and membership programs, where charges begin automatically unless a consumer takes steps to cancel. Federal law requires companies using these models to clearly explain how billing works and to obtain clear consent before charging consumers. Instacart did not admit wrongdoing and agreed to follow the settlement terms.

The stipulated order sets enforceable standards for Instacart’s delivery pricing disclosures, refund representations, and subscription enrollment practices, and subjects the company to compliance and monitoring requirements for a ten-year period.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Alexandra Agraz
Alexandra Agraz is a former Diplomatic Aide with firsthand experience in facilitating high-level international events, including the signing of critical economic and political agreements between the United States and Mexico. She holds dual associate degrees in Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, and Film, blending a diverse academic background in diplomacy, culture, and storytelling. This unique combination enables her to provide nuanced perspectives on global relations and cultural narratives.

Related Articles

Instacart logo behind a smartphone displaying the company’s grocery delivery and pickup app.

DoorDash to Buy Instacart for $17 Billion, Raising Antitrust Concerns

DoorDash has agreed to acquire grocery delivery rival Instacart for approximately $17 billion, a deal that would combine two of the country’s largest delivery platforms and face federal antitrust review over its potential effects on grocery prices, competition, and gig workers.The companies announced the agreement Thursday, October 29, 2026, offering... Read More about DoorDash to Buy Instacart for $17 Billion, Raising Antitrust Concerns

Person in a blue shirt taps a smartphone displaying a “Cancel subscription?” prompt with yes and no options.

NYC’s ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule Takes Effect With New Refund Protections for Consumers

New York City’s new “Click-to-Cancel” rule took effect October 1, 2026, requiring businesses to make subscriptions as easy to end as they are to start and giving city regulators new authority to act when companies block or delay cancellation.The rule covers automatic renewals and continuous service subscriptions and requires businesses... Read More about NYC’s ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule Takes Effect With New Refund Protections for Consumers

A person holds a credit card in front of a laptop on a desk with papers spread out.

Payment Processor Agrees to Pay $12 Million After FTC Says It Helped More Than 1,000 Sham Merchants

A payment processing company has agreed to pay $12 million and accept sweeping restrictions on its business after the Federal Trade Commission accused it of helping more than 1,000 sham merchants process unauthorized charges on consumers’ credit and debit cards.The FTC sued 5967 Ventures LLC, which does business as Humboldt... Read More about Payment Processor Agrees to Pay $12 Million After FTC Says It Helped More Than 1,000 Sham Merchants

Close-up of a smartphone screen displaying the Zillow Real Estate & Rentals app page, featuring the Zillow logo, blue app icon, and a house image in the header.

Zillow, Redfin Agree to FTC Antitrust Settlement Over $100 Million Rental Listings Deal

Zillow and Redfin have agreed to settle an FTC antitrust case over their $100 million rental listings deal, with Redfin required to reenter the rental advertising market and compete independently with Zillow under a proposed federal court order.The settlement would keep the companies' rental listings partnership in place while removing... Read More about Zillow, Redfin Agree to FTC Antitrust Settlement Over $100 Million Rental Listings Deal

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter