Skip to main content

Judge Narrows Blake Lively Lawsuit Against Justin Baldoni Ahead of Trial

by Camila Curcio | Apr 03, 2026
Gavel resting on a wooden judge's bench in a courtroom, with a judge blurred in the background.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

A federal judge has significantly reduced the scope of a high-profile lawsuit filed by Blake Lively against Justin Baldoni and associated production partners tied to the film It Ends With Us, eliminating the majority of her claims just weeks before the case is set to go to trial in New York.

In a detailed ruling issued on Thursday, U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman dismissed 10 of the 13 claims originally brought by Lively, including allegations of sexual harassment and defamation. The ruling leaves three claims intact: retaliation under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) against production entities IEWUM and Wayfarer, an aiding-and-abetting FEHA retaliation claim against TAG, and a breach of contract claim tied specifically to the film’s Contract Rider Agreement (CRA) against IEWUM.

Central to the court’s decision was the classification of Lively’s working status during production. Judge Liman found that Lively operated as an independent contractor rather than an employee, a distinction that proved decisive in dismissing her sexual harassment claims under the statutes cited in her complaint.

While Lively’s federal employment-based claims were dismissed on that basis, her California claims were analyzed separately under different legal frameworks.

The ruling stated there was no material dispute that Lively exercised significant control over her role and creative decisions on the film, placing her outside the legal protections typically afforded to employees in workplace harassment cases. As a result, the court concluded that her claims could not proceed under the specific legal framework she invoked.

The court dismissed Lively’s harassment claims under California law, but not based on any categorical rule about conduct occurring within a scripted performance. Instead, the court evaluated whether the alleged conduct met the legal threshold for a hostile work environment under the specific circumstances presented. In analyzing individual incidents, including a disputed slow-dance scene, the court found that, considered in isolation and in context, that interaction was not sufficient to support a harassment claim. The judge noted it was not clearly beyond what might reasonably occur in a filmed performance and, viewed on its own, did not support an inference of sex-based hostility.

The court emphasized that harassment claims must be evaluated based on the totality of the circumstances, and noted that other alleged conduct in the case presented a closer question. Ultimately, the harassment claims were dismissed based on the applicable legal standards and factual context, not because the court adopted any rule that conduct within a performance setting cannot constitute harassment.

The judge pointed to other elements of the case that could support Lively’s remaining claims. These include allegations that she was pressured to participate in a partially nude birth scene without appropriate safeguards, such as a closed set or an intimacy coordinator, conditions that, according to the ruling, may have violated contractual agreements.

The court also referenced testimony that Baldoni made comments about Lively’s personal life that were unrelated to the film’s creative process, suggesting that such remarks could be interpreted as inappropriate and potentially relevant to the broader dispute.

While dismissing the majority of claims, the judge allowed Lively’s retaliation allegations under FEHA to proceed, indicating that there was sufficient evidence for a jury to consider whether the defendants’ actions crossed a legal line.

The ruling points to allegations that Lively may have faced reputational harm following her complaints, including claims of coordinated public relations efforts that could be interpreted as extending beyond legitimate self-defense.

In addition, the court allowed a breach of contract claim to proceed, but only with respect to the Contract Rider Agreement (CRA) and only against IEWUM. Other contract-related claims were dismissed.

The dispute first drew widespread attention in late 2024, following a report that detailed Lively’s initial complaint and allegations of a coordinated campaign against her.

Attorneys for Baldoni and the other defendants characterized the ruling as a significant legal victory, emphasizing the dismissal of the federal harassment claims. Lively’s legal team responded by emphasizing that the dismissal was based on technical legal grounds rather than a rejection of the underlying allegations. In a statement, her attorney said the case would now focus on what they described as a broader pattern of retaliation following Lively’s complaints about on-set conditions.

The trial remains scheduled to begin on May 18 in Manhattan federal court.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Camila Curcio
Camila studied Entertainment Journalism at UCLA and is the founder of a clothing brand inspired by music festivals and youth culture. Her YouTube channel, Cami's Playlist, focuses on concerts and music history. With experience in branding, marketing, and content creation, her work has taken her to festivals around the world, shaping her unique voice in digital media and fashion.

Related Articles

Rebel Wilson poses in a black off-the-shoulder dress at a Toronto International Film Festival event.

Judge Rejects Bid to Punish Rebel Wilson Over Alleged False Testimony and Deleted Evidence

A California judge has rejected a request to dismiss Rebel Wilson's claims or impose more than $474,000 in financial penalties over allegations that the actress lied under oath, manipulated evidence, and helped create anonymous websites targeting a producer of her film The Deb.Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Thomas Long denied... Read More about Judge Rejects Bid to Punish Rebel Wilson Over Alleged False Testimony and Deleted Evidence

A hand holds a smartphone displaying Netflix’s Baby Reindeer page in front of a television showing the series title.

Netflix’s ‘Baby Reindeer’ Appeal Faces Dismissal in Fiona Harvey’s $170M Defamation Case

Netflix’s attempt to overturn a ruling allowing Fiona Harvey’s $170 million Baby Reindeer defamation lawsuit to move forward has hit a new obstacle after a federal appeals court said it may lack jurisdiction to hear the company’s appeal.The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued an order on... Read More about Netflix’s ‘Baby Reindeer’ Appeal Faces Dismissal in Fiona Harvey’s $170M Defamation Case

Hands typing on a laptop with anonymous website comment overlays, a tablet and smartphone nearby.

Justin Baldoni PR Adviser Accused of Lying Under Oath About Secret ‘Smear’ Sites

Hollywood crisis publicist Melissa Nathan is facing accusations that she lied under oath about her role in anonymous websites used to attack rival publicist Stephanie Jones, after newly produced texts and payment records allegedly tied her directly to the content.Jones says the records show Nathan personally directed an employee to... Read More about Justin Baldoni PR Adviser Accused of Lying Under Oath About Secret ‘Smear’ Sites

Lizzo in a pink sleeveless dress with large hoop earrings blows a kiss at a public event.

Judge Dismisses Stylist’s Harassment Lawsuit Against Lizzo’s Touring Company

A federal judge has dismissed the remaining harassment and discrimination claims brought by wardrobe stylist Asha Daniels against Lizzo’s touring company, ending the nearly three-year lawsuit stemming from the singer’s 2023 European tour.U.S. District Judge Fernando L. Aenlle-Rocha granted summary judgment Tuesday in favor of Big Grrrl Big Touring Inc.,... Read More about Judge Dismisses Stylist’s Harassment Lawsuit Against Lizzo’s Touring Company

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter