Skip to main content

Meta Faces Lawsuit Over Instagram’s Alleged Harm to Teen Mental Health

by LC Staff Writer | Oct 20, 2024
A person holds a smartphone displaying the Instagram app, with the Instagram logo blurred in the background.
Photo Source: NurPhoto - Getty Images by Lorenzo Di Cola via cnbc.com

A Massachusetts court ruled on Friday that Meta Platforms must face a lawsuit alleging it deliberately designed addictive features on its Instagram platform, which harm young users’ mental health. Suffolk County Superior Court Judge Peter Krupp denied Meta’s request to dismiss the case brought by Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, who claimed Meta violated state consumer protection laws and created a public nuisance.

The lawsuit accuses Meta of intentionally designing features on Instagram, such as push notifications and "like" buttons, to exploit psychological vulnerabilities in teens, including their "fear of missing out." The state also alleges that Meta executives, including CEO Mark Zuckerberg, ignored internal research showing that Instagram’s design was harmful to teens despite being aware of these risks.

Meta’s defense rested heavily on Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a federal law that typically shields internet platforms from liability for user-generated content. However, Judge Krupp ruled that the law didn’t apply in this case because Massachusetts was targeting Meta’s own business conduct—such as its failure to protect users and misleading statements about Instagram's safety measures—not third-party content.

Krupp's ruling is significant because it distinguishes between holding platforms accountable for user content and their own business practices, such as misleading public safety claims. This decision allows the lawsuit to proceed, potentially setting a precedent for other cases targeting tech companies for the way they design and market their platforms.

The lawsuit claims that features like push notifications, "likes," and the endless scroll feature were specifically designed to keep young users engaged for longer periods, profiting from their addiction. According to internal Meta data cited by the lawsuit, these features contributed to a deterioration in teen mental health. Yet, executives failed to implement suggested changes to improve user well-being.

Massachusetts is one of several states that pursued separate legal action against Meta after a federal judge in California similarly refused to dismiss a multi-state lawsuit that accuses the company of fueling teen mental health problems. This case adds to growing pressure on tech companies over their responsibility to mitigate harm caused by social media platforms.

With the dismissal denied, Massachusetts can now proceed with its claims against Meta. Attorney General Campbell expressed satisfaction with the ruling, stating that it allows the state to push forward with efforts to hold the company accountable for the alleged harm to young users. A Meta spokesperson, meanwhile, reiterated the company’s disagreement with the ruling but said the evidence will demonstrate Meta’s commitment to supporting young people.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

LC Staff Writer
Law Commentary’s Staff Writers are dedicated legal professionals and journalists who excel at making complex legal topics accessible and relatable. They are committed to providing clear, accurate commentary that helps readers understand the impact of legal news on their daily lives.

Related Articles

Meta logo mounted on the glass facade of an office building.

Meta Settles Teen Social Media Addiction Lawsuits, Avoids Trial

Meta has settled with two teenagers who accused Instagram and Facebook of deliberately encouraging addiction and harming their mental health, leaving Snapchat's parent company, Snap, to face a Los Angeles jury alone.The latest settlement, announced Friday, October 30, 2026, resolves claims brought by an 18-year-old Mississippi woman identified in court... Read More about Meta Settles Teen Social Media Addiction Lawsuits, Avoids Trial

Smartphone displaying Facebook, X, YouTube, Instagram, Snapchat and TikTok app icons beneath a glowing “Social Media” label.

Meta, Google and TikTok Sue to Block California Social Media Ban for Kids

Meta, Google and TikTok filed separate federal lawsuits Wednesday, November 4, 2026, seeking to block a California law that would prohibit addictive social media features for children under 16. The companies argue that the restrictions violate the First Amendment by allowing the state to control how online platforms recommend and... Read More about Meta, Google and TikTok Sue to Block California Social Media Ban for Kids

Close-up of the Snapchat app logo on a smartphone screen.

Snapchat Settles Teen Addiction Lawsuits, Avoids Los Angeles Trial

Snapchat parent Snap Inc. has settled lawsuits brought by two young women who accused the platform of deliberately encouraging addictive behavior and contributing to their mental health problems, ending the second Los Angeles social media addiction trial during jury selection.The agreements, announced Monday, November 2, 2026, resolve claims brought by... Read More about Snapchat Settles Teen Addiction Lawsuits, Avoids Los Angeles Trial

Meta logo displayed on a smartphone, with a blurred person standing in the background.

Meta Hit With $25 Billion Penalty for Misleading Facebook Users About Privacy

Meta Platforms has been ordered to pay New Mexico $25 billion after a jury found that Facebook misled consumers about their personal information and privacy protections, exposing the social media giant to one of the largest corporate penalties in U.S. history.The October 21, 2026, judgment follows a jury verdict finding... Read More about Meta Hit With $25 Billion Penalty for Misleading Facebook Users About Privacy

TikTok app logo displayed on a smartphone screen.

TikTok Sued by Arizona Over Claims It Designed App to Addict Children and Hid Risks

Arizona has sued TikTok, accusing the social media company of deliberately designing its app to addict children and teenagers while concealing mental health risks and misleading parents about safety features intended to protect young users.Attorney General Kris Mayes filed the lawsuit on October 8, 2026, in Maricopa County Superior Court,... Read More about TikTok Sued by Arizona Over Claims It Designed App to Addict Children and Hid Risks

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter