Skip to main content

Michigan Supreme Court Denies Refunds for College Students Over COVID-19 Campus Changes

by Amanda Tjan | Aug 30, 2024
A group of college students smiling and walking on campus, holding school supplies.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Images by Syda Productions

The Michigan Supreme Court denied college students' requests for refunds for disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, ruling Friday that students are not entitled to compensation for the shift to online classes or changes in campus housing.

The decision comes after the court heard arguments nearly a year ago but ultimately let a 2022 appeals court ruling stand. The appeals court had found that no specific promise of in-person classes was made when the 2019-20 school year began. Additionally, the court noted that housing contracts contained clauses addressing extraordinary circumstances, such as those posed by the pandemic.

The lawsuits, which targeted Eastern Michigan University, Central Michigan University, and Lake Superior State University, argued that students should receive refunds because the education and housing services they paid for were altered significantly. However, the court's decision extends to other public universities in Michigan that made similar changes during the pandemic.

In its ruling, the appeals court concluded that the plaintiffs "failed to demonstrate that the defendant universities breached any contractual agreement with them." The Michigan Supreme Court upheld this ruling with a brief two-sentence order, approved by a 5-2 majority.

Justice David Viviano, joined by Justice Richard Bernstein, dissented, arguing that the case should be sent back to the Court of Claims for further examination. Viviano pointed out that the plaintiffs were not arguing that the universities failed to provide the classes for which they registered but rather that the format of those classes had changed in a way that was inconsistent with their expectations.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Amanda Tjan
Amanda is a freelance journalist interested in current events regarding policy and healthcare. She earned her bachelor's degree in social welfare from the University of California, Berkeley. She is currently attending medical school at Western University of Health Sciences and aspires to improve the lives of others through science and human connection.

Related Articles

U.S. Supreme Court building with its neoclassical columns and steps under a partly cloudy sky.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump's Appeal Over $59 Million in UC DEI Grant Cuts

The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16, 2026, rejected the Trump administration's appeal seeking to restore cuts to approximately $59 million in federal research grants awarded to University of California researchers, leaving intact a ruling that found the cancellations likely violated the First Amendment.The justices denied review in Trump v.... Read More about Supreme Court Rejects Trump's Appeal Over $59 Million in UC DEI Grant Cuts

Exterior view of the United States Supreme Court building under a blue sky with clouds.

Washington Supreme Court Joins Jurisdictions Denying Covid-Related Insurance Claims

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, many businesses were forced to close their doors in light of mandatory quarantines and lockdowns. Customer-facing businesses were hit especially hard, including restaurants, movie theaters, medical offices, fitness centers, and others. Many sought coverage for the millions in lost revenue under their “business... Read More about Washington Supreme Court Joins Jurisdictions Denying Covid-Related Insurance Claims

Image of the Ashford University building with the university's logo displayed prominently.

Appeals Court Mostly Affirms Multi-Million Dollar Civil Judgment Against Online University

“What Ashford University did to its students was unconscionable and illegal,” said the California Attorney General who sued the online institution and won over $22 million in penalties. A California appellate court lowered the amount by just under one million because of statute of limitations violations, but the defendants, Ashford... Read More about Appeals Court Mostly Affirms Multi-Million Dollar Civil Judgment Against Online University

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter