We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Viewing as a visitor in
Legal News, Information & Blogs
Netflix’s ‘Baby Reindeer’ Appeal Faces Dismissal in Fiona Harvey’s $170M Defamation Case
Netflix’s attempt to overturn a ruling allowing Fiona Harvey’s $170 million Baby ReindeerDefamationA false statement presented as fact that harms another person’s reputation and meets the legal requirements for a defamation claim.Read more → lawsuit to move forward has hit a new obstacle after a federal appeals court said it may lack jurisdiction to hear the company’s appeal.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued an order on October 6, 2026, giving Netflix 14 days to either voluntarily dismiss its appeal or explain why the court has authority to consider it. Briefing in the appeal has been put on hold while the jurisdiction question is resolved.
If the appeal is dismissed, the case could return to federal district court in Los Angeles and resume proceedings toward trial after being stalled during Netflix’s appellate challenge.
Harvey sued Netflix in June 2024 after viewers identified her as the apparent inspiration for Martha, the stalker portrayed by Jessica Gunning in the hit series created by and starring Richard Gadd. Harvey is seeking at least $170 million and alleges that the show falsely portrayed her as a convicted stalker who sexually assaulted Gadd and spent years in prison.
She denies those allegations and argues that Netflix damaged her reputation by presenting the series as a true story.
The latest appellate dispute stems from a September 2024 ruling by U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner, who rejected Netflix’s attempt to strike Harvey’s core defamation claim under California’s anti-SLAPP law.
Anti-SLAPP laws are designed to quickly dispose of lawsuits targeting protected speech. Netflix argued that Harvey’s claims arose from its exercise of free-speech rights and should therefore be dismissed before the case advanced further.
Klausner disagreed that the case could be thrown out at that stage.
His ruling emphasized the distinction between dramatizing real events and presenting allegedly fictionalized details as fact. Each episode of Baby Reindeer opens with the statement, “This is a true story,” which Klausner said could invite viewers to understand the events depicted as factual.
The judge also found meaningful differences between what Gadd accused Harvey of doing in real life and what Martha does in the series.
Among them, Martha is depicted as a twice-convicted stalker who ultimately pleads guilty and is sentenced to prison. Harvey maintains that she has never been criminally convicted or imprisoned for stalking Gadd.
“There is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law,” Klausner wrote in the 2024 ruling.
He also pointed to differences between allegations of inappropriate touching and the sexual assault portrayed in the series, as well as between alleged physical confrontations and the more serious violence shown on screen.
Netflix has maintained that the series is a dramatized account of Gadd’s experiences and has defended his right to tell his story. The company also argued that Harvey could not establish that viewers would reasonably understand Martha to be her.
Klausner rejected that argument at the dismissal stage, finding that Martha and Harvey shared specific characteristics that could support Harvey’s claim that viewers identified her.
Harvey’s lawsuit followed intense online efforts to uncover the identities of the people who inspired characters in the series. Although Gadd publicly urged viewers not to speculate about their real-life counterparts, Harvey was identified online shortly after the show became a global hit.
Netflix appealed Klausner’s anti-SLAPP ruling in October 2024, pausing the district court case and delaying a trial that had originally been scheduled for May 2025.
The legal landscape changed while that appeal was pending.
In October 2025, the full Ninth Circuit ruled in a separate case, Gopher Media LLC v. Melone, that federal appellate courts generally cannot immediately review the denial of a California anti-SLAPP motion before a case reaches final judgment.
That decision overturned earlier Ninth Circuit precedent that had allowed defendants to bring those appeals while litigation was still underway.
Citing Gopher Media, the appeals court said in Harvey’s case that it may lack jurisdiction over Netflix’s challenge. Netflix can now attempt to show why its appeal should be treated differently. If it submits such an argument, Harvey will have 10 days to respond.
The appeals court has not ruled on whether Harvey’s defamation allegations are true or whether Netflix is ultimately liable. The current dispute concerns only whether Netflix can challenge Klausner’s anti-SLAPP ruling at this point in the litigation.
Harvey’s core defamation case therefore remains unresolved. Netflix’s next filing will determine whether the Ninth Circuit continues considering the appeal or sends the long-running Baby Reindeer dispute back toward the trial court.
Share This Article
If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.
Camila studied Entertainment Journalism at UCLA and is the founder of a clothing brand inspired by music festivals and youth culture. Her YouTube channel, Cami's Playlist, focuses on concerts and music history. With experience in branding, marketing, and content creation, her work has taken her to festivals around the world, shaping her unique voice in digital media and fashion.
Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital is seeking to further narrow Maya Kowalski’s lawsuit, arguing that Florida law protects it from liability for actions taken during the child abuse investigation at the center of Netflix’s Take Care of Maya documentary.In an October 30, 2026, filing, the hospital asked a Florida state...
Read
More about Johns Hopkins Seeks to Cut 'Take Care of Maya' Claims After $213M Reversal »
A California judge has rejected a request to dismiss Rebel Wilson's claims or impose more than $474,000 in financial penalties over allegations that the actress lied under oath, manipulated evidence, and helped create anonymous websites targeting a producer of her film The Deb.Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Thomas Long denied...
Read
More about Judge Rejects Bid to Punish Rebel Wilson Over Alleged False Testimony and Deleted Evidence »
Dan Schneider’s defamation lawsuit against the creators of Quiet on Set: The Dark Side of Kids TV has been thrown out on appeal after a California court found the documentary could not reasonably be understood as accusing the former Nickelodeon producer of sexually abusing children.California’s Second District Court of Appeal...
Read
More about Dan Schneider’s ‘Quiet on Set’ Defamation Case Thrown Out Over Child Abuse Claim »
Netflix is facing the threat of a defamation lawsuit from prediction market platform Kalshi, which claims a trailer for an upcoming documentary about betting markets falsely implies the company violated a court order barring it from offering sports wagering contracts in Nevada.Kalshi's attorneys sent Netflix a cease-and-desist letter demanding the...
Read
More about Kalshi Threatens Netflix With Defamation Suit Over Prediction Markets Documentary Trailer »