A former Penn State University fraternity member accused of supplying cocaine to two fraternity houses has been indicted on seven federal drug charges that carry a maximum possible sentence of life in prison, nearly three months after Pennsylvania prosecutors charged 14 people in an alleged campus trafficking operation.
Agostino Abbatiello, 24, of Westbury, New York, was charged Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with one count of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and six counts of cocaine distribution. Prosecutors allege he supplied Sigma Chi and Delta Upsilon with large quantities of the drug between January 2023 and December 2024, sometimes delivering as much as a kilogram at a time.
Abbatiello allegedly purchased cocaine from suppliers in Philadelphia and New York, recruited others to transport it to State College and enlisted fraternity brothers and pledges to prepare it for resale. Investigators say the drugs were cut and packaged inside fraternity houses before being sold primarily to Penn State students, with payments collected through cash and electronic payment applications.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday previously identified Abbatiello and former student Thomas Robinson as the main suppliers in the operation. A statewide grand jury investigation led to charges against 14 people on August 17, including 13 who attended Penn State during the period under investigation. The charges ranged from misdemeanor drug possession to felony conspiracy and participation in a corrupt organization.
Some fraternity pledges were allegedly recruited to cut and package cocaine as part of their introduction to fraternity life. State prosecutors said the operation involved senior fraternity members who coordinated purchases, distribution and sales.
Six people charged with felonies in the state investigation had their cases sent to Centre County Court in September following preliminary hearings or waivers. Abbatiello was among those whose charges advanced.
Penn State also stripped Delta Upsilon of university recognition for at least four years Wednesday after an internal investigation uncovered serious hazing and drug-related misconduct. University officials found that new members had been subjected to sleep deprivation, physical punishment, intimidation and acts of violence, including waterboarding.
The investigation also corroborated allegations of drug misuse and distribution. Delta Upsilon had been under interim suspension since August, when the state charges were announced. Its international organization subsequently removed chapter leadership and suspended the remaining members.
Sigma Chi, where Abbatiello was a member, lost university recognition in 2021 and continues operating independently of Penn State's fraternity oversight system.
Abbatiello pleaded not guilty to the federal charges Wednesday. U.S. District Judge Sean Camoni ordered him into federal custody after he had previously been released on $250,000 bail in the state prosecution. A federal detention hearing is scheduled for November 24.