Skip to main content

Seattle Family Awarded $10 Million in a Wrongful Pregnancy Lawsuit

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Nov 29, 2020
A healthcare professional administering a vaccination to a patient's arm.
Photo Source: Shutterstock Image

A Seattle family has been awarded $10 million after a wrongful pregnancy lawsuit was filed against the federal government. The lawsuit came after the victim, Yesenia Pacheco, was inadvertently given a flu shot instead of a birth control shot during her routine visit.

The federal judge who tried the case, U.S. District Judge Robert Lasnik, awarded the parents 2.5 million dollars in damages. The child was awarded 7.5 million dollars for expenses relating to her medical care, education, and anything else deemed necessary for her quality of life.

Injection Mix-Up

On September 30, 2011, Pacheco came into the NeighborCare Health Center for her quarterly birth control injection of Depo-Provera. Gloria Rodriguez, the nurse who administered the shot, accidentally gave Pacheco the flu shot instead of the contraceptive shot. Court documents explain that the mix-up happened because of an influx of patients who were coming in for the flu shot that day.

Pacheco learned of the mistake when she called the clinic to get her next dose of Depo-Provera. During the call, the clinic could only provide records of a flu shot being administered, not the birth control injection. Pacheco came back to the clinic, where she was tested and received confirmation that she was pregnant.

The birth control contraceptive Depo-Provera is a highly effective one; however, the shots need to be taken on a consistent quarterly basis within specific time frames to protect against pregnancy. By the time Pacheco tried to schedule her next round of Depo-Provera, it was too late.

Child Born in Wrongful Pregnancy to Face Lifetime of Health Challenges

Pacheco's daughter, who is now eight years old and in the third grade at a Seattle elementary school, was born with an array of health issues. According to court documents, Pacheco's daughter suffers from a unique birth defect called bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria (PMG). Because of the birth defect, Pacheco's daughter lives with slurred speech, limited language skills, cognitive delays, vision issues, epilepsy, and other health complications. The family's attorneys, Mike Maxwell and Steve Alvarez, reveal that the child has an IQ of 70 and expressed that she will need care throughout her life.

Pacheco was 16 years old when she came to the United States as an El Salvadoran refugee. Since then, she has gone to the Neighborcare Health Clinic routinely for her quarterly injection of the birth control.

The court found that the defendant was negligent in the standard of care and that a "wrongful pregnancy" or "wrongful life" ruling was the case's necessary outcome. Court documents state the following,

"Mrs. Rodriguez was thinking only of walk-in flu shots when she encountered Ms. Pacheco. She failed to confirm why Ms. Pacheco was there, to document consent to the flu vaccine or a change in the orders, or to advise Ms. Pacheco of the side effects of a flu shot and/or the consequences of skipping a Depo-Provera injection."

Because the Neighborcare Health Clinic is a federally funded clinic that serves low-income and uninsured patients, the federal government was named as the defendant in the lawsuit.

Lawyers from the Justice Department are asking the court to place some of the awarded money in a reversionary trust. This trust would allow any money that goes unused by the child to return to the federal government.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Close-up of the Seal of the Superior Court of California, County of San Diego, mounted on a wall.

San Diego Treatment Center Hit With $105 Million Verdict After Counselor Reported Sexual Harassment

A San Diego jury awarded $105 million to a substance abuse counselor who said she was fired after reporting sexual harassment, a hidden camera in an employee bathroom, and concerns about patient safety at an opioid treatment facility.The May 12 verdict in Michelle Giaquinta v. San Diego Health Alliance, Inc.... Read More about San Diego Treatment Center Hit With $105 Million Verdict After Counselor Reported Sexual Harassment

Gavel and wooden family figures on a desk with a person signing documents in the background, symbolizing a child-welfare settlement.

Washington Child Welfare Agency to Pay $80 Million in Negligence Settlement Over Injured Siblings

Washington state’s child welfare agency, the Department of Children, Youth and Families, will pay $80 million to settle claims that it failed to protect two children who were left in the care of their biological parents despite repeated warnings about their safety.The two children at the center of the case,... Read More about Washington Child Welfare Agency to Pay $80 Million in Negligence Settlement Over Injured Siblings

A person wearing a blue jacket with "FBI" printed in yellow on the back, standing on a street near a vehicle.

Federal Judge Awards Almost $2 Million in Civil Lawsuit After Finding FBI Agent Negligent in Kidnap Victim’s Shooting Death

A federal judge in Houston, Texas, as part of his judgment stemming from a 2018 case, awarded about $2 million in damages resulting from an FBI agent’s actions. The FBI agent shot and killed a kidnapped Texas man in a suburban home during a failed rescue mission. The family of... Read More about Federal Judge Awards Almost $2 Million in Civil Lawsuit After Finding FBI Agent Negligent in Kidnap Victim’s Shooting Death

A close-up of hands gripping jail cell bars, symbolizing confinement and lack of support.

Woman Who Gave Birth on Jailhouse Floor Files a Federal Lawsuit After Pleas for Help Went Ignored

A Maryland woman has filed a federal lawsuit alleging that her constitutional rights were violated after she was forced to give birth in a concrete jail cell without any assistance or access to medical support. After being arrested and jailed for a probation violation just days before her due date,... Read More about Woman Who Gave Birth on Jailhouse Floor Files a Federal Lawsuit After Pleas for Help Went Ignored

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter