Skip to main content

Surrogate Challenges California Couple’s Parental Rights After Giving Birth in Texas

by Alexandra Agraz | Aug 17, 2026
Close-up of a newborn's feet with curled toes resting on a soft blue blanket.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

A newborn with a severe heart defect is receiving medical care in Texas with his intended parents after the woman who carried him challenged their legal parentage, continuing a dispute that began months before his birth.

McKenna West, an Alaska woman who served as a gestational surrogate for California couple Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, gave birth to the boy in Dallas on Aug. 12. A California court had already recognized Gilkar and Ahmed as the child's legal parents, while a Dallas judge later barred West from making medical decisions for the newborn or representing herself as his mother.

West has been denied contact with the baby and plans to continue challenging the rulings, according to her attorney. Gilkar and Ahmed remain with the child while he receives specialized treatment.

The dispute began months before the birth after doctors diagnosed the fetus at about 20 weeks with hypoplastic left heart syndrome, or HLHS, a congenital condition in which the left side of the heart is severely underdeveloped. Treatment generally involves several surgeries beginning soon after birth and continued cardiac care.

West claims Gilkar and Ahmed pressured her to terminate the pregnancy after learning of the diagnosis. The couple disputes her account. In an Alaska court filing, their attorneys said the parties initially agreed to terminate the pregnancy and that West made the first appointment before changing her mind and cutting off communication with them.

As the pregnancy continued, Gilkar and Ahmed said they consulted specialists and arranged for West to deliver in California so the baby could begin treatment with a cardiac team there. West instead traveled to Texas, where she sought an order recognizing her as the child's mother and giving her authority over his medical care.

The couple has also accused West of violating the surrogacy agreement. Surrogacy agreements commonly set out the parties' responsibilities during pregnancy, including medical care and how serious complications will be handled. Those terms can support a contract claim if one side says the agreement was broken, but they do not necessarily allow one person to compel another to undergo a medical procedure.

The alleged contract breach does not by itself determine who is legally recognized as the child's parent. In a gestational surrogacy arrangement, the person who gives birth is not necessarily the child's legal parent. State laws differ, and some allow intended parents to obtain a court judgment establishing parentage before birth.

California law allows intended parents in qualifying gestational surrogacy arrangements to seek a parentage order before birth. A California trial court entered such a judgment recognizing Gilkar and Ahmed as the child's parents, and a state appellate court later rejected West's effort to prevent it from taking effect.

The California judgment remained legally significant after West traveled to Texas. Under the U.S. Constitution's Full Faith and Credit Clause, states generally must recognize valid judgments issued by courts in other states.

Paxton's own filing acknowledges that Texas must recognize a valid California parentage judgment, while arguing that the order does not prevent Texas from enforcing its laws governing a child's medical care.

Shortly before the birth, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton intervened, alleging that Gilkar and Ahmed had not agreed to authorize necessary surgery and asking the Dallas court to ensure the newborn received medically indicated treatment.

The couple disputed the suggestion that they intended to deny their child care. Ahmed said in a court filing that they had been seeking access to the baby's doctors so they could make informed medical decisions and that refusing treatment had not been their position.

A Dallas judge ordered that medically necessary care could not be withheld or obstructed and restricted the child's removal, discharge or transfer while the court considered the dispute. The order also provides for an emergency hearing if medically indicated treatment is refused.

Parents generally have broad authority to make medical decisions for their children, but courts can intervene when withholding necessary treatment would place a child's health or life at serious risk. Those rules apply regardless of the separate dispute over who holds parental rights.

The temporary restrictions on West remain in place ahead of the next hearing in the Texas case, scheduled for Aug. 25.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Alexandra Agraz
Alexandra Agraz is a former Diplomatic Aide with firsthand experience in facilitating high-level international events, including the signing of critical economic and political agreements between the United States and Mexico. She holds dual associate degrees in Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, and Film, blending a diverse academic background in diplomacy, culture, and storytelling. This unique combination enables her to provide nuanced perspectives on global relations and cultural narratives.

Related Articles

The U.S. Supreme Court building stands against a blue sky.

Supreme Court Rejects Surrogate’s Emergency Bid in Baby Custody Fight After Abortion Request

The Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected an emergency request from surrogate McKenna West in the bitter custody fight over a baby born with a life-threatening heart defect after she refused the intended parents’ request to terminate the pregnancy.Justice Elena Kagan denied West’s bid to suspend a California court order recognizing... Read More about Supreme Court Rejects Surrogate’s Emergency Bid in Baby Custody Fight After Abortion Request

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton speaks onstage in a dark suit and pink tie.

Family Sues Ken Paxton Over Pregnant Woman’s Death, Blames Texas Abortion Ban

The family of a pregnant Texas woman who died from preeclampsia has sued Attorney General Ken Paxton and her medical providers, alleging the state’s abortion restrictions deterred doctors from ending her pregnancy during a medical emergency.Tierra Walker, 37, died in San Antonio on Dec. 30, 2024, while about 20 weeks... Read More about Family Sues Ken Paxton Over Pregnant Woman’s Death, Blames Texas Abortion Ban

Demonstrators gather outside a building holding signs in support of transgender rights and against Texas Governor Abbott's order regarding gender-affirming care for minors.

Texas Judge Blocks Governor’s Order to Treat Gender-Related Medical Care as Child Abuse

According to Texas Governor Gregg Abbott, “subjecting” Texas children to procedures or drugs that aid in “gender transitioning” constitutes “child abuse.” He directed the state’s Family and Protective Services Agency (DFPS) to investigate any family that aids its children in medical transitioning. A Texas judge issued a temporary injunction against... Read More about Texas Judge Blocks Governor’s Order to Treat Gender-Related Medical Care as Child Abuse

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter