We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Photo Source: Nathan Congleton/NBC via usmagazine.com
The New York Times has filed a lawsuit in New York state court seeking to recover more than $150,000 in attorney’s fees and costs from Justin Baldoni’s production company, Wayfarer Studios, after defeating defamation claims earlier this year. The Times argues the prior case was a baseless Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, or SLAPP, brought to intimidate and punish its reporting on matters of public interest.
In the new Civil ComplaintA complaint is the formal pleading that generally begins a civil lawsuit. It identifies the parties, states the legal and factual basis for the plaintiff’s claims, explains why the court has authority to hear the case, and asks the court for a specific form of relief.Read more →, filed September 30 in New York County Supreme Court, the Times contends that Wayfarer’s defamation action “lacked any basis in fact or law” and forced the newspaper to spend substantial resources in its defense. Under New York’s anti-SLAPP law, defendants who prevail in meritless suits targeting free speech may recover damages, including attorney’s fees.
The dispute traces back to a December 21, 2024, article and video published by the Times that reported on actor Blake Lively’s complaint to the California Civil Rights Department. Lively accused Baldoni, who directed the film It Ends With Us, and Wayfarer CEO Jamey Heath of sexual harassment and workplace retaliation. The Times’ reporting, based on official filings and supporting documents, also cited communications suggesting Baldoni and Heath engaged a crisis public relations manager to discredit Lively.
Wayfarer and its affiliates responded by suing the Times for defamation, false light, fraud, and breach of implied contract. They argued the paper defamed the company by suggesting Baldoni and Heath orchestrated a smear campaign, and claimed the Times violated an agreement by publishing its story before a requested comment deadline.
On June 9, 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed all claims against the Times with prejudice. Judge Lewis J. Liman ruled that the defamation claim failed because the reporting was protected under New York’s fair report privilege, which shields journalists when reporting on official documents and proceedings. The court also found no evidence that the Times acted with actual malice, a necessary element for defamation involving public figures. The opinion noted that the underlying complaint and documents contained “numerous messages strongly suggesting” Wayfarer and its executives sought to spread negative stories about Lively, making the Times’ reporting reasonable.
The court separately held that New York does not recognize a false light cause of action, rejecting that claim outright. As for fraud and breach of implied contract, the court found the claims “meritless,” concluding that no enforceable promise was made in the Times’ pre-publication email to Wayfarer. The judge noted that Wayfarer’s attorney had, in fact, provided a comment before publication and that his response was included in the article.
The Times now seeks reimbursement of its legal fees and other relief, saying Wayfarer’s claims were filed to harass and intimidate rather than to pursue legitimate legal remedies.
Share This Article
If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.
Alexandra Agraz is a former Diplomatic Aide with firsthand experience in facilitating high-level international events, including the signing of critical economic and political agreements between the United States and Mexico. She holds dual associate degrees in Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, and Film, blending a diverse academic background in diplomacy, culture, and storytelling. This unique combination enables her to provide nuanced perspectives on global relations and cultural narratives.
Hollywood crisis publicist Melissa Nathan is facing accusations that she lied under oath about her role in anonymous websites used to attack rival publicist Stephanie Jones, after newly produced texts and payment records allegedly tied her directly to the content.Jones says the records show Nathan personally directed an employee to...
Read
More about Justin Baldoni PR Adviser Accused of Lying Under Oath About Secret ‘Smear’ Sites »
Justin Baldoni is asking a Los Angeles judge to rule that QBE Insurance was required to cover his legal defense in the Blake Lively litigation that grew out of It Ends With Us, potentially shifting a substantial portion of his legal costs to the insurer.Attorneys for Baldoni and Wayfarer Studios...
Read
More about Justin Baldoni Asks Judge to Make QBE Cover Legal Bills From Blake Lively Case »
A federal jury in Alabama has awarded former University of Alabama basketball player Kai Spears more than $9 million after finding The New York Times liable over a 2023 article that falsely placed him at the scene of a fatal shooting involving people connected to the school's basketball program.The March...
Read
More about Jury Awards Kai Spears $9.35 Million in New York Times Defamation Case »
A federal judge has awarded Blake Lively more than $400,000 in attorneys’ fees and costs stemming from a defamation claim brought against her by Justin Baldoni and others connected to Wayfarer Studios.U.S. District Judge Lewis J. Liman awarded Lively $363,245.40 in attorneys’ fees and $44,206.35 in costs Wednesday, bringing the...
Read
More about Blake Lively Awarded More Than $400,000 in Legal Fees From Justin Baldoni »