Sanctions are tools courts use to enforce procedural rules, protect the judicial process, compensate for certain litigation-related harm, and deter improper conduct.
A sanction is not one specific penalty. Depending on the governing rule and circumstances, a court can impose monetary penalties, order payment of certain attorney's fees, strike filings, restrict evidence, dismiss claims, enter default, issue reprimands, or impose other appropriate measures.
Federal and state courts have multiple sources of sanctioning authority, so the applicable standard depends on the conduct involved.
What Are Rule 11 Sanctions?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 governs representations made to a federal court in pleadings, written motions, and other covered papers.
By presenting a filing, an attorney or unrepresented party certifies that it is not being presented for an improper purpose, that its legal contentions are supported by existing law or a nonfrivolous argument for changing the law, and that factual assertions have or are likely to obtain evidentiary support as permitted by the rule.
If Rule 11 is violated, a federal court can impose an appropriate sanction after notice and an opportunity to respond.
Does Losing a Case Mean a Party Can Be Sanctioned?
No.
A legal argument does not violate Rule 11 simply because the judge rejects it.
The rule expressly permits nonfrivolous arguments seeking to extend, modify, or reverse existing law or to establish new law. Courts distinguish unsuccessful advocacy from filings that lack the required legal or factual basis or are pursued for an improper purpose.
What Is the Rule 11 Safe Harbor?
When one party seeks Rule 11 sanctions against another, federal procedure generally provides a 21-day safe-harbor period.
The sanctions motion must first be served on the opposing party rather than immediately filed with the court. If the challenged filing is withdrawn or appropriately corrected within the specified period, the motion generally cannot then be filed under that provision.
A court can also initiate certain Rule 11 proceedings on its own.
What Can a Sanction Include?
Rule 11 provides that a sanction should be limited to what is sufficient to deter repetition of the misconduct or comparable conduct by others.
Possible sanctions include nonmonetary directives, penalties payable to the court, and in qualifying circumstances an award of reasonable attorney's fees and expenses resulting from the violation.
Other procedural rules and a court's inherent authority can authorize different sanctions for discovery violations, contempt, disobedience of orders, bad-faith litigation conduct, or other misconduct.
Are Lawyers the Only People Who Can Be Sanctioned?
No. Depending on the rule involved, sanctions can apply to attorneys, law firms, parties, or others involved in litigation.
Rule 11 itself permits sanctions against an attorney, law firm, or party responsible for a violation, subject to restrictions on particular monetary sanctions.
Why Sanctions Matter
Courts depend on parties and lawyers to comply with procedural rules and present claims and defenses responsibly.
Sanctions provide a means of addressing misconduct without turning every violation into a separate lawsuit. Their purpose can include deterrence, enforcement of court authority, protection of opposing parties, and preservation of the integrity of judicial proceedings.