Skip to main content

Appellate Court Rules Trans Women Can't Compete in Miss United States of America LLC Beauty Pageants

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Nov 15, 2022
Contestants in evening gowns at a beauty pageant event.
Photo Source: 2017 Miss USA – Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S., 14/05/2017 - Three out of the five finalists, Miss South Carolina Megan Gordon, Miss Illinois Whitney Wandland and Miss Minnesota Meredith Gould, stand on stage. (REUTERS/David Becker)

In a recent appellate court ruling, the rights of transgender women to participate in Miss United States of America LLC beauty pageants were challenged in what some activists have called a setback for the trans community.

The U.S court of appeals for the ninth circuit has upheld a lower court’s ruling that operators of the Miss United States of America pageant cannot be compelled to allow openly transgender women to participate in the competition. According to the court, the organization's ability to express its belief that the competition should cater to only “natural born” females would be obstructed otherwise.

The ruling was the result of a 2019 lawsuit brought forward by transgender woman and activist, Anita Green. Green sued pageant organizers after she was denied the ability to compete in the annual Miss Oregon beauty pageant.

According to Green, the organization’s rules regarding Miss United States of America were a violation of anti-discrimination laws in Oregon. Green’s argument took specific aim at the organization's competition rule that only allowed “natural born” females to compete.

Miss United States of America LLC is similarly-named but not to be confused with Miss USA pageants. Under the guidelines of Miss USA pageants, transgender women are allowed to participate in the competitions.

Green’s lawsuit argued that “this policy, intentionally designed to exclude the specific class to which plaintiff belongs – transgender females – is discriminatory because it denied plaintiff the full and equal advantages and privileges of defendant’s services in violation of Oregon’s public accommodations law.'”

Despite Green arguing that the pageantry guidelines for who could participate were arbitrary, U.S. District Judge Michael W. Mosman dismissed Green's claims.

“This case brought awareness to an issue many people were and still are unaware of and that issue is that discrimination against transgender people is still actively happening in the private and public sector even within the pageant circuit,” Green shared in a statement following the initial ruling.

In the most recent ruling, the appellate court shared, "The panel noted that it is commonly understood that beauty pageants are generally designed to express the 'ideal vision of American womanhood.’ The Pageant would not be able to communicate 'the celebration of biological women' if it were forced to allow Green to participate."

The ruling went on to express that forcing the pageant to allow transgender women to compete “would fundamentally alter the Pageant's expressive message in direct violation of the First Amendment."

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Gloved hand holding vials labeled estrogen and testosterone hormones.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Bid to Restrict Hormone Therapy for Transgender Federal Prisoners

The Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected the Trump administration’s request to immediately restore restrictions on gender-affirming care in federal prisons, leaving in place a lower-court order that protects access to hormone therapy and other accommodations while the case continues.The October 21, 2026, decision does not determine whether the Federal Bureau... Read More about Supreme Court Rejects Trump Bid to Restrict Hormone Therapy for Transgender Federal Prisoners

Two female athletes from Martin Luther King High School standing in front of the school building, wearing t-shirts that promote girls' sports.

MLK High School Students Say School District Prioritized Transgender Athlete Over Female Athletes in New Lawsuit

Two female athletes and their parents from Martin Luther King High School in Riverside County, California, have filed a lawsuit against the Riverside Unified School District and other school officials. In their lawsuit, they allege that school officials violated their constitutional rights in favor of promoting an unqualified transgender athlete.... Read More about MLK High School Students Say School District Prioritized Transgender Athlete Over Female Athletes in New Lawsuit

Birth certificates laid out with the title "Certificate of Live Birth."

Transgender Individuals Cannot Change ‘Sex’ on Birth Certificate, Rules Tennessee Judge

A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit that pushed to reverse a Tennessee law prohibiting transgender individuals from changing the sex listed on their birth certificate. When the lawsuit was filed, Tennessee was one of only three states with such laws. The other states included Kansas and Ohio, both of which... Read More about Transgender Individuals Cannot Change ‘Sex’ on Birth Certificate, Rules Tennessee Judge

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter