Skip to main content

California Sues ExxonMobil Over Plastic Waste and Deceptive Recycling Claims

by LC Staff Writer | Sep 23, 2024
ExxonMobil facility with large storage tank and industrial structures in the background.
Photo Source: Kathleen Flynn/Reuters via The Guardian

California has filed a lawsuit against Exxon Mobil, accusing the energy corporation of deceiving the public for years about the environmental impact of plastic production. The lawsuit follows a nearly two-year investigation by California Attorney General Rob Bonta, which concluded that Exxon had intentionally misled consumers about the feasibility of plastic recycling while promoting its "advanced recycling" technologies. Bonta issued a statement stating, “Today’s lawsuit provides the most complete picture yet of Exxon Mobil’s decades-long deception, and we are asking the court to hold Exxon Mobil fully accountable.”

The state’s civil suit, filed in San Francisco County Superior Court, alleges that Exxon Mobil violated several California laws, including those related to False AdvertisingFalse advertising involves materially false or misleading statements made in commercial advertising or promotion about products, services, or commercial activities.Read more →, water pollution, and Unfair CompetitionUnfair competition is a broad area of law addressing deceptive, misleading, or wrongful business practices that harm competitors, consumers, or another party's commercial identity.Read more →.

Bonta’s investigation revealed that Exxon had been promoting its "advanced recycling" process, which converts hard-to-recycle plastics into fuel through a method called pyrolysis. However, the lawsuit claims that this process has had limited success and only a small fraction of the plastic waste processed ends up being converted into recycled plastic. According to Bonta’s office, the promotion of this technology was largely a "public relations stunt."

Historically, the company has downplayed the environmental impacts of fossil fuel production and plastic manufacturing, suggesting that recycling is a viable solution to plastic pollution. Despite internal warnings dating back to the 1970s regarding the limitations of recycling, ExxonMobil publicly promoted recycling initiatives to deflect calls for regulations and restrictions on plastic use.

The lawsuit is grounded in both state and federal law. Bonta argues that Exxon’s actions constitute a public nuisance under California law, as the plastic pollution generated by the company harms the environment, waterways, and public health. Additionally, the suit claims that Exxon violated California’s false advertising and unfair competition laws by misrepresenting the effectiveness of its recycling efforts.

The state is seeking an InjunctionAn injunction is a court order requiring a person or organization to stop specified conduct or, in some circumstances, to take a particular action.Read more → to prevent Exxon from "further pollution, impairment, and destruction," as well as to stop the company from making "any further false or misleading statements about plastics recycling and its plastics operations."

Exxon Mobil has rejected the accusations, stating that "suing people makes headlines but doesn’t solve the plastic waste problem." A spokesperson for the company argued that advanced recycling is a legitimate solution and criticized California’s efforts, claiming that “California has done "nothing to 'advance' recycling."

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

LC Staff Writer
Law Commentary’s Staff Writers are dedicated legal professionals and journalists who excel at making complex legal topics accessible and relatable. They are committed to providing clear, accurate commentary that helps readers understand the impact of legal news on their daily lives.

Related Articles

Two BIC pocket lighters, one blue and one green, lie side by side on a gray surface.

BIC Files 6 Lawsuits Against California Retailers Over Fake Lighters

BIC Corporation has filed six federal lawsuits against California gas stations, vape shops, and wholesalers, accusing them of selling counterfeit pocket lighters bearing the company’s logos and designs.The lawsuits, filed October 23, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, target businesses accused of distributing imitation... Read More about BIC Files 6 Lawsuits Against California Retailers Over Fake Lighters

Close-up of a hand holding a red gas pump nozzle at a fueling station.

California Drivers Sue Gas Station Operators Over Alleged AI Price-Fixing Scheme

California drivers have filed a proposed class action accusing major gas station operators and a fuel-pricing software company of using artificial intelligence to keep gas prices higher than they would be in a competitive market.The lawsuit, filed June 22 in federal court in Sacramento, names Kalibrate, the company behind an... Read More about California Drivers Sue Gas Station Operators Over Alleged AI Price-Fixing Scheme

A law professor standing in a courtroom setting with arms crossed, wearing a purple dress.

Conservative Group Sues University for Access to Private Emails of Law Professor Who Authored a New Legal Strategy for Forcing Fossil Fuel Companies to Pay for Climate Damage

A law professor who helped draft legislation to force oil, gas, and coal companies to pay for harm done to the climate due to their work is now being pressured by a conservative group through a lawsuit against her University. Rachel Rothschild, an Assistant Professor at the University of Michigan... Read More about Conservative Group Sues University for Access to Private Emails of Law Professor Who Authored a New Legal Strategy for Forcing Fossil Fuel Companies to Pay for Climate Damage

Logo and storage tanks of Plains All American Pipeline against a cloudy sky.

Plains All American Pipeline Reaches $230M Settlement Over 2015 California Oil Spill

A $230 million settlement has been reached in a lawsuit brought forward by fishermen and property owners in Southern California against a Houston-based oil pipeline. The Plains All American Pipeline was the subject of a lawsuit after thousands of barrels of crude oil spilled onto the beaches of Southern California... Read More about Plains All American Pipeline Reaches $230M Settlement Over 2015 California Oil Spill

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter