Skip to main content

Plains All American Pipeline Reaches $230M Settlement Over 2015 California Oil Spill

by Nadia El-Yaouti | May 23, 2022
Logo and storage tanks of Plains All American Pipeline against a cloudy sky.
Photo Source: Oil storage tank with the logo of Plains All American Pipeline LP stand at the Paulsboro Refining Company refinery in Paulsboro, New Jersey, file photo, April 8, 2016. (Luke Sharrett/Bloomberg)

A $230 million settlement has been reached in a lawsuit brought forward by fishermen and property owners in Southern California against a Houston-based oil pipeline.

The Plains All American Pipeline was the subject of a lawsuit after thousands of barrels of crude oil spilled onto the beaches of Southern California on the Gaviota Coast. The oil spill was the result of a corroded pipeline that was leaking without warning.

In May 2015, the pipeline began seeping oil and ultimately destroyed miles of beach along the sound. The spill also impacted the local ecosystem, killing hundreds of seabirds, seals, and other wildlife. As a result of the spill, several fishermen lost their livelihoods and tourism took a hit in the area.

As a result of the settlement, Plains All American Pipeline has agreed to pay a combined $230 million to those impacted. Forty-six million dollars will go to individuals who own property along the coast. Another $184 million will go to fishermen and fish processors who were impacted by the spill.

The settlement comes after a $60 million agreement Plains reached with the federal government to settle federal allegations that the pipeline violated safety regulations.

According to the federal investigation that followed, an estimated 123,000 gallons of crude oil spilled into the pacific. However, other experts estimate that the number could be as high as 630,000 gallons of oil.

Federal investigators found that Plains All American Pipeline missed several opportunities that could have prevented or limited the spill. In addition to failing to detect that the crude oil was leaking, the pipeline operators did not act quickly to mitigate the leak.

Operators of the pipeline who were based in Texas nearly 1,000 miles away oversaw the performance of the pipeline and had at some point turned off an alarm that would have notified them there was a leak. Because this alarm was turned off, there was no indication that the pipeline was leaking. Investigators detail that this avoidable misstep resulted in operators restarting the pipeline once it had been shut off. As a result, more oil was pumped into the waterway.

Following the spill, Plains All American issued an apology and moved forward with cleanup operations. According to their 2017 annual report, the spill cleanup efforts cost an estimated $330 million. In addition to the cleanup, the company moved forward with implementing a plan that would prevent such a tragedy from happening in the future.

Following the settlement, attorney Matthew Preusch who represented the plaintiff in the suit shared, "This settlement should serve as a reminder that pollution just can't be a cost of doing business, and that corporations will be held accountable for the environmental damage they cause.”

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Exterior of a Panda Express restaurant with red awnings, brick facade, and panda logo.

Panda Express Agrees to Pay Over $1 Million to Resolve California Hazardous Materials Training Lawsuit

Panda Express Restaurant Group Inc. has agreed to pay more than $1 million to resolve a civil lawsuit filed by California prosecutors alleging violations of state hazardous materials safety laws at its restaurant locations. The lawsuit was brought by the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office in coordination with prosecutors from... Read More about Panda Express Agrees to Pay Over $1 Million to Resolve California Hazardous Materials Training Lawsuit

A group of Greenpeace supporters standing outside the Morton County Memorial Courthouse, holding a banner that reads "ENERGY TRANSFER: WE WILL NOT BE SILENCED."

Greenpeace Is Gutted by Verdict Assessing $666.9 Million in Damages Over Pipeline Protests From 15 Years Ago

Fifteen years after oil pipeline company Energy Transfer and subsidiary Dakota Access filed a lawsuit regarding protests by Native Americans and Greenpeace, a jury found the Netherlands-based Greenpeace International, Greenpeace USA, and their funding arm Greenpeace Fund Inc., liable for defamation and more. The now teetering organization was found legally... Read More about Greenpeace Is Gutted by Verdict Assessing $666.9 Million in Damages Over Pipeline Protests From 15 Years Ago

Night view of smoke and flames rising from a train derailment site in Palestine, Ohio, with an illuminated landscape.

Lawsuit Seeks Medical Testing and Damages Following Explosive Ohio Train Derailment

A train derailment that happened in Palestine, Ohio, on February 3rd has led to a class action lawsuit filed by local residents who demand answers after the 150-car train derailed, caught on fire, and leaked hazardous chemicals including vinyl chloride into the air and environment. Officials have still been unable... Read More about Lawsuit Seeks Medical Testing and Damages Following Explosive Ohio Train Derailment

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter