Skip to main content

Federal Administration Faces Immigration Blowback

by Miranda Polley | Oct 25, 2019
Close-up of a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services document with the Department of Homeland Security seal, surrounded by red, white, and blue flag ribbons.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Immigration policy under the current federal administration has met with mixed results both in terms of public opinion and the courts. Under President Trump, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has faced criticism for its draconian treatment of migrants in border detention facilities. Likewise, recent changes in policy and procedure at the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), such as implementing a narrower definition of birthright citizenship for children born to U.S. parents abroad, has led many critics to claim that the federal government’s aim is largely to curb all immigration and to punish immigrants, rather than effect meaningful and positive reform.

The administration’s actions, on the whole, have sparked a national debate about the extent of executive power and whether statutory and constitutional checks and balances limit the executive’s purview over immigration policy. While federal courts are generally loath to place limits on executive power concerning foreign affairs and immigration, the Trump administration has tested those limits. Most recently, federal judges blocked two separate rules attempted by the administration.

The first rule change sought to eliminate the 20-day limit on how long children can remain in adult detention facilities. Despite the criticism leveled at the administration for the state of the border detention centers and the familial separation policies, the administration has persisted in seeking to broaden rather than constrain the use of these facilities. The administration’s policy conflicted with a decades-old court order known as the Flores settlement agreement that sets minimum standards of care for immigrant children in detention. While Trump officials have pointed to the agreement as an obstacle to keeping immigrant families together (they claim they are forced to keep immigrant parents detained pending court proceedings while children must then be shipped off to Department of Health and Human Services custody), supporters of immigrant rights hold to the agreement as a necessary check on the administration’s treatment of migrant families. A federal judge recently ruled that the Flores agreement does indeed still hold, preventing the administration from removing the 20-day limit for detaining children.

The second rule shot down by the courts would have allowed the administration to deport tens of thousands of immigrants without a hearing. Immigrants facing deportation are typically granted a short, initial hearing before a judge to learn their rights and how their case will proceed. Immigrants then wait for a full hearing before an immigration judge makes a final decision. Under certain circumstances, the process can be expedited towards removal; specifically, when individuals are arrested within 100 miles of a land border. The administration sought to expand these speedy removal proceedings to any immigrants who arrived in the country within the last two years. The rule would have given ICE wide latitude to engage in fishing expeditions in communities across the country and quickly deport any unauthorized immigrants discovered. A U.S. district judge recently ruled that the administration failed to follow proper administrative procedures in establishing the new policy, preventing an estimated 20,000 people annually from facing these expedited removal proceedings and losing their day in court.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Miranda Polley
Miranda Polley has been crafting legal content for the web since completing law school in 2010. Her expertise lies in preparing compelling copy for various lawyer and law firm websites, leveraging her skills as a proficient legal writer. Miranda ensures that the content not only informs the reader but also adheres to SEO best practices, maximizing its reach across targeted audience segments.

Related Articles

U.S. Supreme Court building with its neoclassical columns and steps beneath a blue sky.

Supreme Court Refuses to Restore Judges' Power to Pause Deportation Cases

The Supreme Court on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, rejected an emergency request to restore immigration judges' authority to temporarily close certain deportation cases, leaving in place a nationwide restriction that prevents judges from using a Biden-era regulation to pause proceedings while immigrants pursue other forms of legal protection.The justices denied... Read More about Supreme Court Refuses to Restore Judges' Power to Pause Deportation Cases

Close-up of a U.S. flag over a document bearing the Department of Homeland Security seal and the words U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.

Federal Judge Strikes Down Trump Immigration Policy Affecting USCIS Applicants From 39 Countries

A federal judge has struck down a Trump administration policy that blocked final decisions on immigration applications filed by people from 39 countries, finding that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services exceeded its authority and unlawfully froze parts of the immigration benefits process.In a ruling issued Friday, U.S. District Chief Judge... Read More about Federal Judge Strikes Down Trump Immigration Policy Affecting USCIS Applicants From 39 Countries

Former President Trump holding up an executive order during a press event.

Keeping Track: Lawsuits Against President Trump and His New Administration Continue to Multiply

We’re only halfway through the first 100 days with our new President and his administration, and the number of lawsuits filed against them is historic. The flurry of new executive orders and cabinet-level decisions have led to over 40 suits, and it’s only early March. By the hour and by... Read More about Keeping Track: Lawsuits Against President Trump and His New Administration Continue to Multiply

People walking with luggage towards an immigration checkpoint.

Trump-Era Immigration Judge Quotas Eliminated, Critics Still Cautious of New Standards

Earlier this week, the Department of Justice said they would be easing quotas for immigration judges that were set during the Trump Administration. The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) is currently developing new performance measures to replace the previous administration’s metrics that “will accurately reflect the reality of an... Read More about Trump-Era Immigration Judge Quotas Eliminated, Critics Still Cautious of New Standards

Two U.S. Border Patrol officers escorting an individual in handcuffs, wearing police vests and with their backs to the camera.

ICE Ends Bond Hearings for Many Undocumented Immigrants Under New Directive

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has issued new guidance instructing agents to limit release options for undocumented immigrants. Under the policy, most individuals who entered the country without authorization will no longer be eligible for bond hearings before an immigration judge. The change is outlined in an internal memo signed... Read More about ICE Ends Bond Hearings for Many Undocumented Immigrants Under New Directive

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter