Skip to main content

Immigration Lawyer Files Lawsuits Against DHS After Agents Seized His iPhone

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Feb 03, 2021
Image of a person holding a locked smartphone with a padlock icon on the screen.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

A Texas immigration lawyer is suing the U.S. Department of Homeland Security after his phone was seized and searched at an airport upon re-entry into the U.S.

Adam A. Malik was returning home from a trip to Costa Rica when he was stopped at the Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport on January 3. Customs and Border Protection agents stopped Malik, selecting him for what is known as a secondary inspection, then seized his phone during the process.

His selection for secondary inspection by CBP agents comes despite Malik being approved for membership in the CBP’s Global Entry Trusted Traveler Program. Malik was approved for the program in 2014, and his latest renewal in 2019 was also approved. The lawsuit states that CBP agent officer Sullivan informed Malik he was randomly selected for review of eligibility in the Global Entry Program during the secondary inspection. It was later believed that the statement made by officer Sullivan was false.

Malik was interrogated separately by at least three different agents. During the line of questioning, Malik was asked about his law practice, his personal life, his parents, and his immigration into the United States. According to the lawsuit, the agents paid close attention to Malik's law practice and asked him questions about the “legal representation he had provided and continues to provide to certain clients, cases that he had taken on, and the identity of certain past and current clients.” Malik answered questions about his personal life but refused to answer questions pertaining to his clients, citing that such information was “privileged information.” It was during this line of questioning where Malik was asked to produce his iPhone and unlock it.

Malik’s lawsuit, which was filed in the Northern District of Texas on January 25, alleges that Malik’s First and Fourth Amendment rights, including his expressive and associational rights and his right to be protected from unreasonable searches and seizures, were violated. Malik also highlights his professional duties to keep the sensitive information provided to him by his clients secure.

The CBP agents justified the search under a CBP directive that allows a basic search of an electronic device without the need for a search warrant so long as there is reasonable suspicion. The directive also allows for a more advanced search in which the device can be connected to equipment that will allow data to be extracted from the device. According to the directive, if there is no probable cause to keep the phone, the phone will be returned to its owner, and any data that is collected by the government gets deleted.

According to his lawsuit, Malik explains that the directive “fails to define ‘reasonable suspicion’ or ‘national security concern.’” The lawsuit goes on to say, “These terms are vague and capricious.”

A day after Malik was stopped at the airport, he received notification from a calling, texting, and voice mail system Flypsi, Inc. The notification alerted Malik that there was a request made for a verification code in order for his FLYP account to be unlocked. During this time, the phone was still in the possession of DHS and CBP. According to Malik, the agency went ahead with searching and reviewing the information on Malik's phone without informing him, thus violating the directive. Malik argues that sensitive information was not removed by a filter team prior to the phone being searched.

Among other allegations, Malik states that the agency violated the directive by holding on to the phone for longer than a brief or reasonable period of time (the phone was held for 22 days, and is currently still held) and that his phone was searched without reasonable suspicion that he violated any laws.

Malik explains in the suit, “If clients and their lawyers believe that adversaries and the government may one day sift through their communications in searches involving unrelated matters, clients are less likely to be candid with their lawyers, and lawyers will hesitate before writing down what they need to write down.”

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Get more Law Commentary in Google's Top Stories.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Close-up of a smartphone screen displaying a Delete data confirmation dialog with a Cancel button, illustrating data erasure on a device.

Samuel Tunick Faces Federal Felony After Phone Was Wiped During Atlanta Airport Search

Samuel Tunick is facing a federal felony after data on his Google Pixel was erased while Customs and Border Protection officers were trying to search the device at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport. His attorneys are challenging the legality of the search, putting the government’s border search powers at the center... Read More about Samuel Tunick Faces Federal Felony After Phone Was Wiped During Atlanta Airport Search

Greg Abbott, the governor of Texas, speaks at a podium with the Texas state seal.

Minnesota Sues Greg Abbott to Force Extradition of ICE Agent Charged in Minneapolis Shooting

Minnesota sued Texas Gov. Greg Abbott on Tuesday, asking a federal court to force him to authorize the extradition of an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent charged with assault in Minneapolis. State officials argue Abbott has a mandatory constitutional duty to return the agent and warn that continued delay could... Read More about Minnesota Sues Greg Abbott to Force Extradition of ICE Agent Charged in Minneapolis Shooting

Stone plaque reading "Internal Revenue Service" affixed to a beige brick wall.

IRS Shared 47,000 Taxpayer Records With ICE. Appeals Court Says It Broke Federal Law

A federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that the Internal Revenue Service broke federal law when it shared more than 47,000 taxpayer records with Immigration and Customs Enforcement under a Trump administration data-sharing system.The unanimous U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld an order blocking the IRS... Read More about IRS Shared 47,000 Taxpayer Records With ICE. Appeals Court Says It Broke Federal Law

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter