Skip to main content

Judge Rejects Royel Otis Guitarist’s Bid to Unmask Reddit Users Behind Misconduct Allegations

by Camila Curcio | Jan 06, 2026
Close-up of a smartphone showing the Reddit app icon, held in a hand against a red background featuring the Reddit logo.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

A federal judge in California has denied a request by Royel Maddell, guitarist for the Australian indie-pop duo Royel Otis, to compel Reddit to identify anonymous users who posted sexual-misconduct allegations about him online.

In a ruling issued late last year, U.S. District Judge William Alsup of the Northern District of California described the application as both “overreaching” and “overburdensome,” concluding that Maddell, whose legal name is Leroy Bressington, failed to meet the legal threshold required to pierce online anonymity.

The dispute stems from a now-deleted thread posted last year on Reddit, where anonymous users accused Bressington of engaging in a sexual relationship with a minor who was allegedly his music student. Other claims in the thread suggested that he had been charged by authorities and dropped by a record label. The allegations circulated at a time when Royel Otis were already facing criticism over the lyrics to their song “Moody,” which some listeners described as misogynistic. The band later issued a statement acknowledging the backlash and apologizing to anyone who felt harmed by the lyrics.

According to court filings, Bressington initially asked Reddit directly to disclose identifying information about the users involved in the thread, including names, IP addresses, phone numbers, and email addresses. After Reddit declined, citing user privacy and legal protections, Bressington sought a court order compelling the company to turn over that data.

Bressington argued that the information was necessary so he could evaluate whether to pursue a DefamationA false statement presented as fact that harms another person’s reputation and meets the legal requirements for a defamation claim.Read more → lawsuit, particularly if the users were located in Australia. But Judge Alsup found that justification insufficient, noting that Bressington had not actually filed a defamation complaint in any jurisdiction.

“The application does not make clear whether Bressington ultimately would follow through” with litigation, Alsup wrote, emphasizing that the guitarist’s legal team stated only that they would be “prepared to initiate” a lawsuit, not that they definitively intended to do so. The judge suggested that seeking expansive discovery before taking concrete legal steps rendered the request premature.

Alsup also pointed to inconsistencies and omissions in Bressington’s application. While the filing explicitly denied some claims, including that Bressington had been charged by authorities, dropped by a label, or accused by an ex-partner, it notably stopped short of directly refuting the central allegation that he had sex with a minor. That absence, the judge wrote, raised “lingering questions” about the scope and credibility of the request.

“[The application] has not specifically rejected as false one of the most basic assertions alleged,” Alsup noted, calling attention to the seriousness of the accusation and the lack of a clear denial within the court filings.

Courts in the United States have generally set a high bar for unmasking anonymous online speakers, particularly when the requesting party has not yet filed a formal lawsuit. Judges often weigh the right to seek legal redress against First Amendment protections and the potential chilling effect on online speech.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Get more Law Commentary in Google's Top Stories.

Camila Curcio
Camila studied Entertainment Journalism at UCLA and is the founder of a clothing brand inspired by music festivals and youth culture. Her YouTube channel, Cami's Playlist, focuses on concerts and music history. With experience in branding, marketing, and content creation, her work has taken her to festivals around the world, shaping her unique voice in digital media and fashion.

Related Articles

Kendrick Lamar performs onstage wearing sunglasses, a black jacket and pink pants while holding a microphone.

Kendrick Lamar's Former Label Defeats Doxxing Claim in Sexual Misconduct Lawsuit

Kendrick Lamar's former record label, Top Dawg Entertainment, has won an appeal defeating a doxxing claim brought by two women who accused its executives of sexual misconduct, after the company publicly identified them despite their decision to sue anonymously.In an October 8, 2026, ruling, a California appeals court found that... Read More about Kendrick Lamar's Former Label Defeats Doxxing Claim in Sexual Misconduct Lawsuit

Hands point toward a tablet displaying the Roblox logo.

Roblox Loses Bid to Stop L.A. County Lawsuit Over Alleged Child Sex Exploitation

Roblox failed in two attempts to stop a Los Angeles County lawsuit accusing the gaming platform of exposing children to sexual predators, grooming and sexually explicit content while promoting itself as safe for young users.Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Dean J. Kitchens rejected Roblox’s challenge to the case and denied... Read More about Roblox Loses Bid to Stop L.A. County Lawsuit Over Alleged Child Sex Exploitation

4chan logo displayed on a black device resting over a colorful backlit computer keyboard.

4chan, Kiwi Farms Lose U.S. Fight to Block UK Online Safety Act Enforcement

4chan and Kiwi Farms have lost their attempt to stop Britain’s online safety regulator in a U.S. court, with a federal judge ruling that Ofcom is protected by foreign sovereign immunity.U.S. District Judge Rudolph Contreras dismissed the lawsuit Tuesday in Washington, D.C., cutting off the forums’ attempt to block Ofcom’s... Read More about 4chan, Kiwi Farms Lose U.S. Fight to Block UK Online Safety Act Enforcement

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter