Skip to main content

Prince Harry, Elton John Ordered to Pay $13 Million Toward Daily Mail Publisher’s Legal Costs

by Alexandra Agraz | Aug 21, 2026
A man in a dark suit and tie speaks into a handheld microphone on stage.
Photo Source: Lev radin/Shutterstock.com

Prince Harry, Elton John and five other public figures have been ordered to pay £9.54 million, about $13 million, toward the legal costs of the Daily Mail’s publisher after losing their privacy case against the company.

High Court Justice Matthew Nicklin ordered the interim payment to Associated Newspapers by August 28. He also ruled that most of the publisher’s recoverable costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis, a standard that can leave the losing side responsible for a greater share of its opponent’s legal expenses.

Nicklin said the way the claims were brought and pursued went beyond the ordinary course of civil litigation. He pointed to the broad and partly speculative nature of some allegations, serious accusations that lacked sufficient supporting evidence and claims that remained in the case even as the evidence changed.

The judge found that the combined conduct was “unreasonable to a high degree.” He did not find that Harry or any of the other six individuals had acted dishonestly and accepted that they had genuine concerns about how private information about them reached Associated’s newspapers.

The August 21 costs order follows Nicklin’s July 7 dismissal of claims brought by Harry, John, Baroness Doreen Lawrence, Elizabeth Hurley, David Furnish, Simon Hughes and Sadie Frost. The seven had accused Associated of obtaining private information through unlawful methods, including phone hacking and the use of private investigators. Associated denied wrongdoing.

After an 11-week trial, Nicklin found that they had not proved that the information challenged in their claims had been obtained unlawfully. Suspicion about newspaper practices or evidence concerning the use of private investigators was not enough without proof connecting unlawful conduct to the specific information at issue.

The latest ruling raises a separate legal issue over what happens when a court concludes that litigation was pursued in an unusually unreasonable way. English courts can require the losing side in a civil case to contribute to the winner’s legal costs. Those expenses are normally assessed on the standard basis, meaning they must be reasonable and proportionate, with doubts generally resolved in favor of the party required to pay.

Indemnity costs apply a stricter standard for the losing side. The expenses must still be reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount, but proportionality does not provide the same limit, and doubts over reasonableness are generally resolved in favor of the party recovering the money.

Courts do not award indemnity costs simply because someone loses a lawsuit. The higher standard is generally reserved for circumstances or conduct outside the normal range of civil litigation. Nicklin concluded that the way the allegations were developed, maintained and presented justified applying that standard to most of Associated’s costs.

The size of the publisher’s bill remains unresolved. Associated says its legal expenses reached approximately £34.5 million, or about $47 million. Nicklin described the figure as exceptionally high and said it appeared excessive, but declined to impose a fixed ceiling before the expenses undergo a detailed review.

Harry and the others have not been ordered to pay the full £34.5 million. If the two sides cannot agree on what Associated can recover, a costs judge will examine the bill and determine which expenses were reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount. Unnecessary, duplicated or otherwise unreasonable charges can still be rejected under the indemnity standard.

The £9.54 million due August 28 is an initial payment while the final costs are determined. How that amount and any additional costs will ultimately be divided among the seven individuals has not yet been resolved.

The court was previously told that the group has combined insurance coverage of approximately £16.2 million for legal costs. The amount claimed by Associated is more than twice that figure, although the publisher will not necessarily recover everything it spent.

Associated Newspapers called the ruling a victory for the Mail and its journalism and said the claims should not have been brought. Harry’s spokesperson did not comment on the August 21 decision. Harry and Lawrence criticized the July dismissal after it was issued, calling the ruling a “complete and obvious whitewash.”

The £9.54 million interim payment is due August 28. The final amount of Associated’s recoverable legal costs has not been determined, and the parties have until October 2 to seek permission to appeal the trial judgment or the costs ruling.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Get more Law Commentary in Google's Top Stories.

Alexandra Agraz
Alexandra Agraz is a managing consultant, former Diplomatic Aide, and guest contributor to Law Commentary. She has firsthand experience facilitating high-level international events, including the signing of significant economic and political agreements between the United States and Mexico. Her consulting expertise spans business strategy, organizational development, and cross-border initiatives. Her academic background includes business management studies at the bachelor's level and dual associate degrees in Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, and Film. Combining experience in diplomacy, business, and storytelling, she brings a multidisciplinary perspective to international affairs, legal developments, and cultural issues.

Related Articles

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor speaks at a wooden podium in a formal interior.

Judge Throws Out Epstein Search Warrants Used in Former Prince Andrew Raids

A British High Court judge has thrown out search warrants used in raids on two homes linked to Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor after police admitted they relied on the wrong legal provision, handing the former prince a procedural victory in an Epstein-related criminal investigation.Mr Justice Hilliard formalized the agreement between Andrew and... Read More about Judge Throws Out Epstein Search Warrants Used in Former Prince Andrew Raids

Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, and Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex, stand side by side outside a modern building.

King Charles Confirms Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Remain Private Citizens After UK Return

King Charles III has confirmed that Prince Harry and Meghan Markle remain non-working members of the Royal Family and are to be treated as private citizens following their return to the United Kingdom, making clear that the couple will not resume official royal duties.The King authorized guidance sent Monday, September... Read More about King Charles Confirms Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Remain Private Citizens After UK Return

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor gestures while wearing a dark suit outside a building.

Former Prince Andrew Challenges Epstein Search Warrants in High Court

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, formerly Prince Andrew, is challenging search warrants used to raid his residences during an investigation into allegations that he shared sensitive government information with Jeffrey Epstein.The former prince has been granted permission to ask Britain's High Court to quash the warrants, which authorized searches of Marsh Farm on... Read More about Former Prince Andrew Challenges Epstein Search Warrants in High Court

A man in a short-sleeve shirt walks with a woman who has long hair, together outdoors at night.

Amy Winehouse's Father Ordered to Pay $1.3 Million to Late Singer's Friends After Losing Baseless Auction Lawsuit

A London judge has ordered Mitch Winehouse, the father of late singer Amy Winehouse, to pay more than $1.3 million to two of his daughter's closest friends after a High Court judge tore apart the lawsuit he brought against them over auctioned memorabilia. Justice Sarah Clarke handed down the costs... Read More about Amy Winehouse's Father Ordered to Pay $1.3 Million to Late Singer's Friends After Losing Baseless Auction Lawsuit

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter