Skip to main content

Restaurant Chain Chopt Faces New Lawsuit After Diner Finds Severed Finger in Her Salad

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Dec 08, 2023
Signage of Chopt Creative Salad Co. restaurant.
Photo Source: Today via Graeme Sloan/Sipa USA/AP Images

A Greenwich, Connecticut, woman filed a negligence lawsuit against the popular restaurant chain, Chopt, earlier this week. Her lawsuit comes after she says she unknowingly chewed on a human finger after she ordered a salad.

Allison Cozzi filed her lawsuit earlier this week with the Supreme Court of Westchester County, New York. In her complaint, Cozzi says that when she dined at the fast-casual restaurant at the Mount Kisco, NY, location this past April, she ordered and was served an arugula salad. While she was eating the salad, she realized that she was “chewing on a portion of a human finger that had been mixed into, and made a part of, the salad."

According to reports, earlier that day, the manager identified as Keny M. was prepping the arugula salad when she inadvertently chopped off her index finger. The lawsuit says the manager went on to seek medical care while "the contaminated arugula was left on the service line and served to customers.

According to local reports, the lawsuit includes an investigation number that matches the investigation number of a case opened by the Westchester County Department of Health against the restaurant’s Mount Kisco location. The Department of Health published some details of the case, including a $900 civil penalty that was made against the restaurant.

The inspection report also shows that a couple of weeks after the incident, the manager in question was interviewed by the health inspector. During the interview, the manager disclosed that both the she and staff "did not realize the arugula was contaminated with human blood and a fingertip."

The lawsuit further alleges that a complaint was reported to the restaurant location and corporate officers, but a complaint was not filed with state health officials as required by state law. On May 25, a hearing was held on the incident resulting in the $900 civil fine. The restaurant was found to have corrected the violations and expressed “contrition for failure to report” the incident.

Cozzi’s lawsuit argues the restaurant was negligent in its conduct and is seeking unspecified damages. Her lawsuit details that after her experience, she suffered "severe and serious personal injuries including: shock; panic attacks; migraine and the exacerbation of migraine; cognitive impairment; traumatic stress and anxiety, nausea, vomiting, dizziness; and neck and shoulder pain."

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

McRib sandwich with barbecue sauce in a McDonald’s box, showing the sandwich’s rib-shaped pork patty.

McDonald's Loses Bid to Toss Lawsuit Over McRib's Missing Rib Meat

A federal judge has rejected McDonald’s bid to dismiss a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing the fast-food giant of misleading customers into believing its McRib sandwich contains actual pork rib meat.U.S. District Judge April Perry in Chicago ruled Friday, October 30, 2026, that consumers could reasonably interpret the sandwich’s name, rib-shaped... Read More about McDonald's Loses Bid to Toss Lawsuit Over McRib's Missing Rib Meat

A glowing pink Lyft sign on a city street at night with tall buildings lit in the background.

Retired Firefighter Says Raw Oysters Led to Cardiac Arrest, Brain Injury

A Cook County lawsuit accuses Gibsons Bar and Steakhouse and several seafood companies of selling contaminated raw oysters that allegedly caused a customer to develop multiple bacterial infections, suffer cardiac arrest and sustain permanent brain damage.Joseph Belgio, 44, a retired Cicero firefighter and Marine veteran, filed the lawsuit Monday in... Read More about Retired Firefighter Says Raw Oysters Led to Cardiac Arrest, Brain Injury

Crispy fried chicken pieces stacked in a Popeyes-branded takeout box on a wooden surface.

Popeyes Sued for More Than $1.5 Million Over Alleged Condom-Like Object in Chicken

Two Texas customers are seeking more than $1.5 million from Popeyes and related companies after claiming they found a condom-like foreign object embedded in fried chicken purchased from a Houston restaurant.Justin Howard of Missouri City and Danielle McKinnon of Katy filed the lawsuit Aug. 3 in Harris County District Court... Read More about Popeyes Sued for More Than $1.5 Million Over Alleged Condom-Like Object in Chicken

Front view of a Taco Bell restaurant storefront with a large sign above the entrance.

Taco Bell and Taylor Farms Face Proposed Class Action Over Cyclospora Outbreak

A Michigan woman has filed a proposed nationwide class action against Taco Bell and several Taylor Farms companies, alleging that contaminated lettuce served by the fast food chain caused Cyclospora infections during a multi-state outbreak.The complaint, filed Monday by Dawn Koss in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District... Read More about Taco Bell and Taylor Farms Face Proposed Class Action Over Cyclospora Outbreak

Round red Chipotle Mexican Grill sign with a white chili pepper logo mounted on the exterior of a building.

Chipotle Sued by Minnesota Woman Hospitalized With Sepsis in Salmonella Outbreak

A Minnesota woman who was hospitalized with sepsis after eating a Chipotle burrito bowl has sued the restaurant chain, claiming contaminated jalapeño peppers caused her illness during a multistate salmonella outbreak linked to 345 cases.Kristen Behne filed the lawsuit Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota.... Read More about Chipotle Sued by Minnesota Woman Hospitalized With Sepsis in Salmonella Outbreak

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter