We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Viewing as a visitor in
National Legal News, Information & Blogs
Judge Allows Trump’s $15 Billion Defamation Lawsuit Against The New York Times to Move Forward
A federal judge has allowed significant portions of President Donald Trump’s $15 billion DefamationA false statement presented as fact that harms another person’s reputation and meets the legal requirements for a defamation claim.Read more → lawsuit against The New York Times, three of its journalists and Penguin Random House to proceed, finding that Trump plausibly alleged Actual MaliceA defamation standard requiring proof that a false statement was published knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for whether it was true.Read more → involving several statements accusing him of serious financial misconduct.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday in Tampa, Florida, issued a split ruling Thursday, November 19, 2026. He dismissed two of Trump’s six counts and ruled that 27 challenged statements could not support his claims, but permitted four counts involving seven statements to move forward.
The decision does not mean Trump has proven the statements were false or defamatory. At this stage, Merryday was deciding whether the allegations in Trump’s Civil ComplaintA complaint is the formal pleading that generally begins a civil lawsuit. It identifies the parties, states the legal and factual basis for the plaintiff’s claims, explains why the court has authority to hear the case, and asks the court for a specific form of relief.Read more → were legally sufficient to survive a Motion to DismissA request asking a court to end all or part of a lawsuit because the claim is legally insufficient or another threshold defect prevents it from proceeding.Read more →. Trump will ultimately face a much higher burden because, as president and one of the country’s most prominent public figures, he must prove that actionable statements were false and published with “actual malice.”
The surviving claims involve the 2024 book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success, written by Times reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, along with an October 2024 Times article by reporter Peter Baker.
Judge Narrows Trump’s Case but Allows Key Claims to Survive
Trump sued The New York Times Company, Craig, Buettner, Baker and Penguin Random House in September 2025, alleging that reporting about his business career, family wealth and financial dealings contained false statements that damaged his reputation and businesses.
Merryday quickly dismissed the first version of the lawsuit without prejudice because the 85-page filing did not comply with federal pleading rules requiring a short and plain statement of a claim. He criticized the complaint for including extensive political rhetoric, argument, and material unnecessary to stating a defamation claim. Trump subsequently filed revised pleadings.
Thursday’s ruling addressed Trump’s second amended complaint.
Merryday dismissed the claims based on a September 2024 article by Craig and Buettner about the construction of Trump’s public image and business persona. He also concluded that 27 of the statements Trump challenged across the publications were not actionable under the governing defamation standard.
Seven statements survived.
Six appear in Lucky Loser. The seventh appeared in Baker’s October 2024 Times article, “For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment.” The surviving statements involve assertions concerning tax-related conduct and other alleged financial or regulatory wrongdoing.
The Case Turns on the “Actual Malice” Standard
Trump faces a constitutional hurdle that applies whenever a public official or Public FigureA person whose prominence or involvement in a public controversy subjects certain defamation claims to the heightened actual-malice standard.Read more → seeks damages for defamatory statements involving matters of public concern.
In the landmark 1964 decision New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a public official generally cannot recover damages for a defamatory falsehood without proving actual malice.
Actual malice has a specific meaning in defamation law. It does not simply mean hostility, political opposition or an intent to harm someone’s reputation.
A plaintiff must show that the defendant published a false statement while knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for whether it was true.
Later Supreme Court decisions have made the standard demanding. Reckless disregard generally requires evidence that the publisher actually had serious doubts about the truth of what was being published or possessed a high degree of awareness that the statement was probably false.
Trump will eventually have to prove actual malice by Clear and Convincing EvidenceA heightened civil standard requiring evidence that makes a disputed fact highly probable, though not necessarily proven beyond a reasonable doubt.Read more →, a higher standard than the ordinary preponderance-of-the-evidence standard used in many civil cases.
Thursday’s decision addresses a much earlier question: whether Trump alleged enough facts to continue pursuing that theory through the litigation.
Why Seven Statements Survived
Merryday found Trump’s allegations concerning seven statements sufficient to support a plausible inference of actual malice at the pleading stage.
One challenged statement from Lucky Loser said Trump received the equivalent of more than $400 million from his father, much of it through allegedly fraudulent tax schemes. Trump disputes that characterization and argues that determining whether complex financial transactions constituted tax fraud would require a detailed examination of financial records and expert tax analysis.
According to the ruling, Trump plausibly alleged that the defendants accused him of planning or committing complicated crimes despite possessing information insufficient to support those conclusions.
The Times and Penguin have argued that the reporting was based on extensive research. According to the court’s discussion of their position, the journalists reviewed approximately 100,000 pages of documents and consulted experts.
Merryday nevertheless concluded that Trump’s allegations concerning the seven statements were sufficient to proceed. The judge reasoned that allegations of criminal activity can present a different issue when the underlying information does not necessarily establish that a crime occurred.
The ruling leaves Trump with an opportunity to seek evidence about how those statements were researched, evaluated, and published. It does not determine what that evidence will show.
Most of Trump’s Challenged Statements Will Not Proceed
The decision is also a substantial narrowing of Trump’s original case. Merryday rejected 27 challenged statements as bases for defamation liability and completely dismissed the two counts involving the September 2024 article by Craig and Buettner. Four counts remain, limited by the court’s ruling concerning which statements can support them. Political criticism, unfavorable characterizations, and expressions of opinion do not automatically become actionable defamation merely because they are harsh or damaging.
A defamation claim ordinarily requires a false assertion of fact capable of defamatory meaning. Statements of protected opinion and assertions that cannot reasonably be understood as stating provable facts receive significant First Amendment protection.
The Times and Penguin argued in seeking dismissal that several of the statements Trump identified were subjective judgments that could not be proven true or false. They have denied defaming Trump and maintain that the lawsuit lacks merit.
Surviving a Motion to Dismiss Is Only the Beginning
The defendants must now answer the surviving claims, and the case can proceed further into discovery. That phase could prove particularly important because actual malice focuses on what journalists and publishers knew or believed at the time the challenged statements were published. Evidence involving source materials, communications, editorial decisions, research and the authors’ assessment of the information available to them could become relevant.
Trump still must prove that the surviving statements were materially false, defamatory and attributable to the defendants under the governing law. He must also satisfy the constitutional actual-malice requirement.
The defendants will have additional opportunities to challenge the claims before trial, including through a motion for summary judgment after discovery. At that stage, Trump would need evidence to support his allegations rather than relying on the allegations themselves.
The distinction separates Thursday’s ruling from a finding that The New York Times or Penguin Random House actually defamed the president.
Merryday found that a limited portion of Trump’s case has crossed the threshold required to remain in court. The much more difficult question, whether Trump can prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendants knowingly or recklessly published false statements about him, remains unresolved.
Share This Article
If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.
Lawrence is an attorney and CEO of Law Commentary. Lawrence draws on his legal and business experience to help make court decisions, litigation, legislation, public policy, and other legal developments more accessible to the general public and to give readers clear context for understanding the law and how it affects businesses, consumers, and communities.
A federal judge has dismissed President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal over its reporting on a sexually suggestive birthday letter allegedly sent to Jeffrey Epstein, finding that his attorneys failed to plausibly allege the newspaper knowingly or recklessly published false information.U.S. District Judge Darrin...
Read
More about Trump Loses $10 Billion Lawsuit Against The Wall Street Journal Over Epstein Letter »
A federal judge ordered President Donald Trump on Thursday, October 22, to answer questions under oath by December 11 in his $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC, threatening to dismiss the case if he fails to comply.U.S. Magistrate Judge Enjoliqué Lett issued the order during a hearing in Miami...
Read
More about Judge Orders Trump to Testify Under Oath in $10 Billion BBC Lawsuit or Face Dismissal »
A federal appeals court has refused to block sanctions against President Donald Trump and his lawyers over a judge’s finding that his $10 billion lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service was improperly used to secure benefits through a settlement with his own administration.A three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit...
Read
More about Appeals Court Leaves Trump Sanctions in Place Over ‘Collusive’ $10 Billion IRS Lawsuit »
A federal judge on Friday rejected President Donald Trump’s latest bid to move his New York hush money conviction into federal court, finding that the request came too late and that evidence Trump claimed was protected by presidential immunity involved personal rather than official conduct.U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein also...
Read
More about Judge Rejects Trump Bid to Move New York Hush Money Conviction to Federal Court »