A complaint is the document a plaintiff files to begin most civil lawsuits.
The complaint tells the court and the defendant what the dispute is about. It identifies the claims being asserted, describes the facts supporting those claims, and states what the plaintiff wants the court to do.
In federal court, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 3 provides that a civil action begins when the complaint is filed with the court. The complaint must then generally be served on the defendant in accordance with the applicable rules.
State courts also use complaints to begin many civil cases, although pleading requirements and terminology vary by jurisdiction.
What Does a Complaint Usually Contain?
A civil complaint generally identifies the plaintiff and defendant, explains the basis for the court’s jurisdiction, states the plaintiff’s claims, and describes the relief being requested.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8 requires a pleading stating a claim for relief to contain a short and plain statement of the grounds for jurisdiction, a short and plain statement showing that the plaintiff is entitled to relief, and a demand for the relief sought.
Federal complaints also follow formatting requirements under Rule 10. They generally include a caption naming the court and parties, numbered paragraphs, and separate counts when doing so makes the claims easier to understand.
The exact amount of factual detail required depends on the court, type of claim, and applicable pleading rules.
Does a Complaint Have to Prove the Case?
A complaint states allegations. It is not itself proof that those allegations are true.
The plaintiff will ordinarily have to support the claims later through evidence developed during discovery, motions, hearings, or trial. The defendant is also entitled to dispute the allegations and raise defenses.
A complaint therefore represents the plaintiff’s formal statement of the case at the beginning of the litigation, not a judicial finding that the defendant did anything wrong.
How Detailed Must a Federal Complaint Be?
A federal complaint must contain enough factual material to state a legally sufficient claim.
The Supreme Court’s decisions in Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly and Ashcroft v. Iqbal developed what is commonly called the plausibility standard. Under that framework, a complaint generally must contain enough factual allegations to make the asserted claim plausible rather than merely possible or speculative.
A court generally does not require the plaintiff to prove the entire case in the complaint. Bare legal conclusions without enough supporting factual allegations, though, may be insufficient.
State pleading standards can differ, and some jurisdictions follow rules that are more or less demanding than the federal standard.
What Happens After a Complaint Is Filed?
After filing, the plaintiff generally must provide the defendant with formal notice of the lawsuit through service of process.
Service ordinarily includes the complaint and a summons informing the defendant that a lawsuit has been filed and that a response is required.
Once properly served, the defendant generally has a limited period of time to respond under the applicable procedural rules.
The response may take the form of an answer, a motion, or another permitted filing.
What Is an Answer to a Complaint?
An answer is the defendant’s formal response to the complaint.
In the answer, the defendant generally admits or denies the plaintiff’s allegations and states applicable defenses. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8 requires a responding party to address the claims asserted and either admit or deny the allegations.
The defendant can also assert affirmative defenses and, in appropriate cases, bring claims against the plaintiff or other parties.
A complaint and an answer therefore perform different functions. The complaint states the plaintiff’s case, while the answer responds to it.
Can a Defendant Ask the Court to Dismiss a Complaint?
Yes.
Instead of immediately answering, a defendant can sometimes file a motion to dismiss.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 permits motions based on several grounds, including lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient service of process, failure to join a required party, and failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.
A Rule 12(b)(6) motion argues that even if the complaint’s properly pleaded factual allegations are accepted as true for purposes of the motion, they are legally insufficient to support a claim for relief.
Granting a motion to dismiss does not always end the lawsuit permanently. Depending on the reason for dismissal and the circumstances, the plaintiff may be permitted to amend the complaint.
What Is an Amended Complaint?
An amended complaint is a revised version of the original complaint.
A plaintiff may amend a complaint to correct errors, add factual allegations, modify legal claims, add or remove parties, or change the relief being requested.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15 permits certain amendments as a matter of course within specified periods. In other circumstances, amendment generally requires the opposing party’s consent or permission from the court. Rule 15 directs courts to freely give leave to amend when justice requires.
Once an amended complaint becomes the operative pleading, the defendant ordinarily responds to that version rather than the superseded original complaint.
What Types of Relief Can a Complaint Request?
A complaint can request different forms of judicial relief depending on the claim.
A plaintiff may seek monetary damages to compensate for an alleged loss or injury. Other cases seek injunctive relief, asking the court to order someone to stop or undertake particular conduct.
A complaint may also request declaratory relief, in which the court determines the legal rights or obligations of the parties without necessarily awarding damages. Federal courts recognize each of these general types of relief in civil litigation.
Some statutes also authorize statutory damages, attorney’s fees, punitive damages, restitution, or other specialized remedies.
Is a Complaint the Same as a Petition?
Not always.
Both can serve as documents that initiate legal proceedings, but courts use the terms differently depending on the type of case and jurisdiction.
Civil lawsuits seeking damages are commonly initiated by complaints. Proceedings involving matters such as habeas corpus, bankruptcy, probate, family law, administrative review, or certain special statutory remedies may begin with a petition instead.
The distinction is largely procedural and depends on the governing law.
Is a Civil Complaint the Same as a Criminal Complaint?
No.
A criminal complaint has a different function.
Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 3, a criminal complaint is a written statement of the essential facts constituting the offense charged and must generally be made under oath before an authorized judicial officer.
A federal criminal prosecution is initiated by the government, not by a private citizen filing a civil-style complaint. Individuals who believe a federal crime has occurred report the matter to law enforcement or prosecutors rather than filing criminal charges themselves in federal district court.
A civil complaint, by contrast, is filed by a plaintiff seeking a civil remedy against a defendant.
Is Everything Alleged in a Complaint Public?
Many complaints filed in court become part of the public court record, although exceptions apply.
Court rules can require sensitive personal information to be redacted. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2, for example, limits disclosure of full Social Security numbers, birth dates, financial account numbers, and the names of minors in public filings.
Courts can also seal particular documents or information when the applicable legal standard is satisfied.
The fact that allegations appear in a public complaint still does not mean a court has determined that they are true.
Why a Complaint Matters
The complaint defines the starting point of a civil lawsuit.
It identifies who is suing whom, explains the claims being asserted, places the defendant on notice of the allegations, and tells the court what relief the plaintiff seeks.
The complaint also helps establish the boundaries of the litigation. The legal claims and factual allegations it contains influence what defenses can be raised, what evidence becomes relevant during discovery, and which issues the court may ultimately be asked to decide.