Skip to main content

Reasonable Doubt

Reasonable doubt is the constitutional standard used to determine whether the prosecution has proven a defendant guilty in a criminal case.

The government must prove every element of a charged crime beyond a reasonable doubt. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that this high burden is required by due process because a criminal conviction can result in loss of liberty, stigma and other serious consequences.

Reasonable doubt does not require absolute certainty. It is also more demanding than the standards used in most civil cases, such as preponderance of the evidence or Clear and Convincing EvidenceA heightened civil standard requiring evidence that makes a disputed fact highly probable, though not necessarily proven beyond a reasonable doubt.Read more →.

Courts use different wording when explaining reasonable doubt to juries. Some describe it as a doubt based on reason and common sense after careful consideration of the evidence. Others caution against attempting to assign it a numerical percentage.

The prosecution carries the burden throughout the criminal case. A defendant does not have to prove innocence or present evidence unless a particular defense places a separate burden on the defendant under applicable law.

If jurors have a reasonable doubt about any element the prosecution must prove, they must return a not-guilty verdict on that charge.

Disputes sometimes arise over whether jury instructions accurately conveyed the standard or whether a juror was willing and able to apply it during deliberations.

Share This Term

Lindsay Clancy sits facing the camera in a gray sweater.

Can Lindsay Clancy Be Tried Again? Massachusetts High Court Takes Up Double Jeopardy Fight

Massachusetts’ highest court has agreed to decide whether Lindsay Clancy can be tried a second time for the deaths of her three children after her first murder trial ended with an 11-1 jury deadlock and allegations that the lone holdout juror was refusing to follow the judge’s instructions on reasonable... Read More about Can Lindsay Clancy Be Tried Again? Massachusetts High Court Takes Up Double Jeopardy Fight

Stanford University courtyard with arched stone colonnades, red-tiled roofs, and Hoover Tower under a clear blue sky.

Stanford Student Faces Rape Trial After Returning From Suspension

A 24-year-old Stanford University student is facing trial on three felony sexual assault charges after returning to campus following a two-year suspension for sexually assaulting another student, according to the university's disciplinary findings.Leo Rossitter was charged in October 2024 with rape of an intoxicated person, oral copulation of an intoxicated... Read More about Stanford Student Faces Rape Trial After Returning From Suspension

Lindsay Clancy sits in court, shown in profile with long brown hair and a beige sweater.

Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

A Massachusetts judge has rejected Lindsay Clancy's attempt to dismiss three murder charges in the deaths of her young children, allowing prosecutors to pursue a second trial after a September mistrial. Her attorneys plan to challenge the decision before the state's highest court.Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan ruled on... Read More about Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

Damon Dash wearing glasses and a gray suit at a public event.

Damon Dash Fights $550K Sale of His Life Story in $25 Million Bankruptcy Case

Roc-A-Fella Records co-founder Damon “Dame” Dash is challenging the $550,000 sale of his life story to a film company, arguing that the proposed agreement could give the buyer control over his personal memories, future activities, and participation in projects against his wishes.Dash's attorney, Mark S. Roher, filed an objection on... Read More about Damon Dash Fights $550K Sale of His Life Story in $25 Million Bankruptcy Case

Larry David sits at a desk holding a phone and gesturing in front of bookshelves.

Larry David Saw O.J. Simpson Hours Before Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman Were Murdered

Larry David saw O.J. Simpson at an exclusive Los Angeles country club on June 12, 1994, just hours before Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered, according to a new biography of the Seinfeld co-creator.The encounter took place during breakfast at the Riviera Country Club, where David was dining... Read More about Larry David Saw O.J. Simpson Hours Before Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman Were Murdered

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter