We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Viewing as a visitor in
Legal News, Information & Blogs
Vacatur
Vacatur means that a court judgment, order, or decision is set aside.
An appellate court can vacate a lower court ruling and send the case back for additional proceedings. Vacatur can also arise when events occurring during an appeal make the underlying dispute Mootness DoctrineThe mootness doctrine generally requires courts to stop deciding a case when later events eliminate the live dispute between the parties. If a court can no longer provide meaningful relief, the case may be dismissed as moot.Read more → before the appellate court has an opportunity to review the earlier judgment.
The Supreme Court has described vacatur as a remedy that effectively erases a judgment that has already been rendered.
What Is Munsingwear Vacatur?
The term Munsingwear vacatur comes from the Supreme Court's 1950 decision in United States v. Munsingwear, Inc.
The doctrine addresses situations in which a civil case becomes moot while appellate review is pending. Vacating the lower court decision can prevent an unreviewable judgment from continuing to create legal consequences even though the losing party no longer has an opportunity to challenge it on appeal.
The Supreme Court continues to use Munsingwear when directing lower courts to vacate judgments in appropriate moot cases.
Is Vacatur Automatic When a Case Becomes Moot?
No. Mootness may require dismissal because no live Article III controversy remains, but vacatur involves a separate equitable determination.
Courts can examine why the case became moot and which party caused the circumstances preventing appellate review. The Supreme Court has made clear that parties do not have an automatic entitlement to erase an adverse judgment merely because the controversy later becomes moot.
Settlement is a common example. When parties voluntarily settle a case and thereby prevent appellate review, the usual justification for vacating the lower court judgment can be considerably weaker.
Does Vacatur Mean the Lower Court Was Wrong?
No. An appellate court can vacate a judgment without deciding whether the lower court's legal reasoning was correct.
When vacatur results from mootness, the point can be precisely that appellate review of the merits is no longer possible. Vacatur addresses what legal effect the unreviewable judgment should retain rather than resolving whether that judgment was substantively right or wrong.
Vacatur Versus Reversal
Vacating and reversing a decision are not the same.
A reversal ordinarily means the appellate court examined the lower court's ruling and concluded that it was legally incorrect.
A vacatur nullifies the judgment. Depending on the circumstances, the appellate court may vacate and remand without deciding the underlying merits.
Why Vacatur Matters
Court decisions can have consequences beyond the immediate parties, including effects on future proceedings and legal rights.
Vacatur gives appellate courts a mechanism for addressing what happens to a judgment when ordinary review becomes impossible or when another legal defect requires the judgment to be set aside.
The Trump administration moved Thursday, November 19, 2026, to end its lawsuit challenging Democrat Mary Peltola's victory in Alaska's U.S. Senate race while asking a federal appeals court to vacate an earlier ruling against the Justice Department.Federal prosecutors told the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit that the...
Read
More about Trump DOJ Moves to Drop Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Win »
A Brooklyn building collapse that killed eight people, including two children, has triggered a criminal investigation after city records revealed that contractors at the neighboring construction site violated a stop-work order and that an earlier inspection documented serious deficiencies in the building's exterior walls.The three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue...
Read
More about Brooklyn Building Collapse Kills 8 After Stop-Work Order Was Violated »
Three songwriters who accused the companies behind BTS of copying their unreleased demo for the group's No. 1 hit "Swim" have dropped their federal copyright lawsuit less than four months after filing it.U.S. District Judge Otis D. Wright II dismissed the case without prejudice Wednesday, November 4, 2026, after Steve...
Read
More about BTS 'Swim' Copyright Lawsuit Dropped After Just 4 Months »
Grammy-winning producer Timbaland has sued his former manager and business manager for more than $15 million, accusing them of taking millions in unauthorized payments, falsifying financial records and mishandling his finances so badly that his home nearly went into foreclosure.In a lawsuit filed Friday, October 30, 2026, in Los Angeles...
Read
More about Timbaland Accuses Former Managers of Stealing Millions in $15M Lawsuit »
Bruce Springsteen endorsed Michigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed on Monday, November 2, 2026, one day before the midterm elections and following a surprise decision by Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens to support his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers.The musician praised El-Sayed as a defender of the Constitution and American democracy, declaring...
Read
More about Bruce Springsteen Backs Abdul El-Sayed as Michigan Democrats Split Over Senate Race »
The Supreme Court on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, rejected an emergency request to restore immigration judges' authority to temporarily close certain deportation cases, leaving in place a nationwide restriction that prevents judges from using a Biden-era regulation to pause proceedings while immigrants pursue other forms of legal protection.The justices denied...
Read
More about Supreme Court Refuses to Restore Judges' Power to Pause Deportation Cases »