Skip to main content

California Mother, Sherri Papini, Sentenced to 18 Months in Prison for Hoax Kidnapping

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Sep 22, 2022
A woman surrounded by a crowd, appearing somber outside a courthouse.
Photo Source: Rich Pedroncelli/AP

A California court has sentenced the infamous Northern California mother, Sherri Papini, to 18 months in prison, after she faked her own abduction.

Forty-year-old Sherri Papini made national headlines at the end of 2016 after she seemingly disappeared while out on a jog. After authorities were alerted of her disappearance, the only trace of her was her phone and strands of her hair tangled up in her headphones that were discarded on the side of the road near her home.

After a statewide three-week hunt and a multi-state search for the mother, Papini suddenly resurfaced on Thanksgiving Day. At the time reports detailed that Papini was picked up along the highway appearing to be beaten, bruised, and disheveled.

During the time she was missing, and in the months after she resurfaced, a number of funds were set up to help Papini adjust back to life. Not long after headlines of her disappearance died down did new headlines pop up indicating that the whole event was a hoax.

Last spring, Papini pled guilty to having staged her abduction and lying to authorities including the FBI about her disappearance. Papini later revealed that she had not been beaten, abused, and branded by her abductors as she initially led on. Instead, Papini spent three weeks hiding out with an ex-boyfriend who later told authorities that he helped Papini evade authorities.

On Monday, Papini stood in front of a court for sentencing and received an unexpected 18 months behind bars, a sentence which was handed down as part of a plea deal. The sentencing was harsher than expected as her attorney and probation officers recommended that Papini spend a month behind bars and seven months in supervised home detention. Prosecutors on the other hand pushed for Papini to serve those seven months behind bars for a total of eight months behind bars instead.

To the surprise of both the prosecution and defense, Senior U.S. District Judge William Shubb opted to go with an 18-month sentence instead. Judge Shubb detailed that because of "the sheer number of people who were impacted," 18 months functioned as a more appropriate sentence. During the three weeks she spent hiding out with her ex-boyfriend, several law enforcement agencies including the FBI spent valuable resources looking for someone who was not, in fact, in danger.

Additionally, when she resurfaced, Papini pointed the finger at two unnamed Hispanic women for having abducted her. Her lie caused unnecessary fear throughout the Latin community, as they suddenly became the subject of suspicion.

Reports indicate that Papini was remorseful during the trial and did not object to the harsh sentence. During her brief testimony, Papini explained, "I'm so sorry to the many people who have suffered because of me," adding, "I am guilty, your honor. I am guilty of lying. I am guilty of dishonor. What is done cannot be undone. It cannot be erased."

Judge Shubb was harsh in his commentary explaining, "Miss Papini is a manipulator. It's not as if Miss Papini has seen the error of her ways...If she had not been caught, she'd still be living the lie."

Following the sentencing, Papini’s attorney William Portanova shared that the ruling was "a fair sentence, even though it's longer than we wished."

"Obviously the court did what it thought was right, and frankly it's difficult to argue with the justice of the sentence," Portanova added. "I'm not really surprised because I understand the court's analysis. ... To the extent the judge wanted to underline the wrongness of her actions and tattoo it further on her soul, he accomplished that for sure."

Along with her sentencing, Papin has been ordered to pay back $309,902 for losses incurred by the Social Security Administration, California Victim’s Compensation Board, the FBI, and Shasta County Sheriff's Office. Of that sum, $150,000 will go to law enforcement agencies for the resources spent on their search, and $128,000 will be paid back for disability payments she received.

During sentencing, Judge Shubb noted that Papini would most likely be unable to pay back the hefty sums of more than $300,000, saying that "unless she wins the lottery” it's unlikely that the agencies who were defrauded would see that money back.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Elizabeth Holmes sits among attendees at a conference, wearing a black turtleneck and blazer.

Elizabeth Holmes Set to Leave Prison Years Early After Judge Cuts Theranos Sentence

Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes is expected to leave her Texas federal prison in August 2027, years before completing her original 11-year sentence for defrauding investors, after a judge cut her prison term and federal credits accelerated her release timeline.Holmes, 42, has been approved for transfer to the Austin Transitional Center,... Read More about Elizabeth Holmes Set to Leave Prison Years Early After Judge Cuts Theranos Sentence

Exterior of the Supreme Court of Nevada building in Las Vegas.

Las Vegas Police Pay $29.5 Million to Woman Wrongfully Imprisoned for 15 Years After Detectives Fabricated Evidence

Las Vegas police have paid Kirstin “Blaise” Lobato $29.5 million after a federal jury found that two detectives fabricated evidence that helped send her to prison for a murder she did not commit. Lobato was arrested at 18 and spent nearly 16 years behind bars before her convictions were overturned.Her... Read More about Las Vegas Police Pay $29.5 Million to Woman Wrongfully Imprisoned for 15 Years After Detectives Fabricated Evidence

Close-up of clear plastic evidence tubes and a document labeled EVIDENCE on a lab bench.

Colorado DNA Analyst Gets 10 Years for Manipulating Evidence in Hundreds of Cases

A former Colorado DNA analyst was sentenced to 10 years in prison Tuesday for manipulating forensic evidence, misconduct that has forced authorities to review more than 1,000 criminal cases and has already reached the Colorado Supreme Court.Yvonne “Missy” Woods, 66, spent nearly three decades as a forensic scientist with the... Read More about Colorado DNA Analyst Gets 10 Years for Manipulating Evidence in Hundreds of Cases

Savannah Guthrie, co-anchor of the Today show, smiles on a red carpet in a black dress with a blazer.

Scrutiny of Nancy Guthrie Investigation Raises Questions About Pima County Liability

More than six months after Nancy Guthrie disappeared from her Tucson area home, scrutiny of the investigation has raised a separate legal question over whether Savannah Guthrie and her family could hold Pima County responsible if mistakes by law enforcement hindered efforts to find her.The Guthrie family has not announced... Read More about Scrutiny of Nancy Guthrie Investigation Raises Questions About Pima County Liability

Elizabeth Holmes, Theranos founder, poses for a head-and-shoulders portrait at a media event.

Why Elizabeth Holmes Is in Prison as New Theranos Documentary Renews Interest in Her Fraud Case

A new documentary about convicted Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes is renewing interest in one of Silicon Valley’s most closely watched criminal fraud cases more than three years after she reported to federal prison.You Can See Everything, a nearly three-hour film directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, made a surprise... Read More about Why Elizabeth Holmes Is in Prison as New Theranos Documentary Renews Interest in Her Fraud Case

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter