Skip to main content

City of Miami Proposes Controversial Plan to Relocate Homeless Population

by Nadia El-Yaouti | Aug 30, 2022
Tents set up in a urban area, highlighting the presence of homelessness.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Commissioners in the city of Miami have voted to move forward with a pilot program that aims to address the city’s homelessness crisis.

While the aim behind the program is well-intentioned, the backlash from the local community has been fierce. Community members along with homelessness advocacy groups have raised valid concerns regarding how the city plans to address homelessness in the area.

The proposed pilot program would allow roughly 100 tiny homes to be built on a nearby barrier island, Virginia Key. The development would be a dent in the crisis of the over 27,000 estimated homeless individuals throughout Florida.

The city has honed in on Virginia Key explaining that it is the best location to build these tiny homes. However, locals have pushed back, arguing that Virginia key is an area for local residents to use commercially and recreationally and serves as a summer camp for children. By establishing a substantially large development of tiny homes for homeless individuals, the sanctity of the area could be disrupted by the unique lifestyle homeless populations are often associated with.

Proponents against the proposed tiny home community also criticized the location because the proposed location is close to a nearby sewage plant. Some critics have gone as far as criticizing the plan as a way to tuck the homeless population out of the general public's eyesight by essentially rounding them up and sheltering them away from the heart of the community.

The city's commissioners who favor the pilot have called the program an opportunity to provide a “transition zone” for homeless individuals throughout the greater Miami area. They explained that the development would provide homeless individuals with basic necessities including shelter, food, access to proper hygiene including showers, and some basic medical services. Officials have also explained that the program would aim to connect homeless individuals with outreach services to further meet their needs.

Commissioner Manolo Reyes has pushed back against the criticism saying, “In my opinion, this is not an encampment that is going to be a concentration camp,” adding, “Nobody’s forcing anybody.”

Not all officials are on board, however. Commissioner Ken Russell voted against the proposed plan, calling it a “bad idea.” He stressed that regardless of the location where the proposed program would take place, the program doesn't offer a permanent solution to a growing problem throughout the community.

Additionally, commissioner Russell explains that relocating homeless individuals to environments miles away from necessities such as grocery stores and workplaces for homeless individuals wanting to secure a job does not do anything to help them in the long run. Commissioner Russell emphasizes that the proposed destination is “miles from anything” and that it only makes it more difficult for homeless individuals to receive the resources and support they need.

Many critics of the program agree with Commissioner Russell, with one of the major critiques being that pop-up tiny homes built at the forefront of hurricane-prone shores would not be the best use of funding for tackling homelessness.

A small business owner on Virginia Key echoed the sentiment. Esther Alonso owns an outdoor center on the Key and shared with local outlet WJLA that Virginia Key is not a practical environment for those who are the most vulnerable.

“This is a harsh environment. When it gets bad, when it gets really humid, or the heat is unbearable, or the mosquitoes are so thick, we can leave,” she explains. “If you’re living here, you can’t. This is it. And it’s a two-mile walk out through a mangrove forest, with a road in between.”

Alonso also emphasized her concern about having a homeless population so close to young children. She explained, “There are children here, this is a beach. And we’re going to bring a large population of primarily homeless men … and we’re going to put them next to a swimming beach where people are running around in swimsuits? I don’t know that’s a good mix.”

The city's Commissioners are set to meet again in September to figure out specific details about the pilot program and how it will play out in implementation.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nadia El-Yaouti
Nadia El-Yaouti is a postgraduate from James Madison University, where she studied English and Education. Residing in Central Virginia with her husband and two young daughters, she balances her workaholic tendencies with a passion for travel, exploring the world with her family.

Related Articles

Sign for "Alligator Alcatraz," an immigration detention center in Florida, with a road leading to the facility surrounded by trees.

Federal Judge Halts Construction at Florida Immigration Detention Center Over Environmental Concerns

A federal judge has ordered Florida to stop construction at a controversial immigration detention center in the Everglades for 14 days, siding temporarily with environmental groups who warn that the project could damage sensitive wetlands and threaten endangered species. Judge Kathleen M. Williams of the U.S. District Court in Miami... Read More about Federal Judge Halts Construction at Florida Immigration Detention Center Over Environmental Concerns

A group of LGBTQ activists holding a California state flag with a rainbow stripe and signs advocating for LGBTQ rights outside a government building.

Palm Springs CA at the Center of Controversial Guaranteed Income Program for LGBTQ Individuals

The city of Palm Springs in California has approved $200,000 to advance a pilot program that would provide a guaranteed universal basic income for individuals who identify as transgender or non-binary or are a member of the LGBTQ community. As part of the program, recipients would receive up to $900... Read More about Palm Springs CA at the Center of Controversial Guaranteed Income Program for LGBTQ Individuals

A Mayor Eric Adams speaking at a press conference, surrounded by other individuals.

NYC Mayor Announces New Directive to Involuntarily Hospitalize Severely Mentally Ill Individuals

New York City Mayor Eric Adams is making national headlines over his latest initiative to combat the needs of homeless individuals throughout the city. Last week, Adams announced his new guidelines titled Mental Health Involuntary Removals. Under this new policy, individuals, mainly those who are homeless, can be involuntarily hospitalized... Read More about NYC Mayor Announces New Directive to Involuntarily Hospitalize Severely Mentally Ill Individuals

Under-construction tiny home with exposed wooden framing against a cloudy blue sky.

California Anchored Tiny Homes Headed Toward Bankruptcy Amid Allegations of Fraudulent Business Practices

Anchored Tiny Homes, a Fair Oaks, California-based building company that once touted itself as a $100 million company, is now exploring bankruptcy options. The news of bankruptcy comes on the heels of hundreds of clients complaining they have been left holding the bag after the building company failed to deliver... Read More about California Anchored Tiny Homes Headed Toward Bankruptcy Amid Allegations of Fraudulent Business Practices

Rescue workers search through the rubble of the collapsed Champlain Towers South in Surfside, Florida, as recovery efforts continue.

As Death Counts Rise Daily in Surfside Condo Disaster, Lawsuits, Building Reforms, & a New Pro-Bono Movement Grow

The deadly condo collapse in Surfside, Florida, now transformed from a search and rescue mission to the recovery of bodies, has ignited numerous lawsuits, federal and local probes, building reforms, and reviews by numerous towns scrambling to avoid a similar disaster. Currently, ninety-five bodies or partial remains have been pulled... Read More about As Death Counts Rise Daily in Surfside Condo Disaster, Lawsuits, Building Reforms, & a New Pro-Bono Movement Grow

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter