Skip to main content

Department of Justice Lawyer Argues the US can Target/Kill American Citizens in Cases of National Security without Review

by Diane Lilli | Nov 18, 2020
Sign on the exterior of the U.S. Department of Justice building, with an American flag in the background.
Photo Source: Shutterstock Image

Two journalists lost their appeal against the US Government on Monday, after alleging they were on a ‘kill list’ while working in Syria.

US citizen and journalist Bilal Abdul Kareem had filed a lawsuit with a second plaintiff, journalist Ahmad Muaffaq Zaidan, a Pakistani-Syrian, against the US Government alleging targeted attacks upon them during their work in Syria in 2019. On Monday, their appeal was dismissed.

Kareem said he was almost killed in five separate attacks in Syria, and alleged the US military was targeting him for death.

Department of Justice Attorney Bradley Hinshelwood, successfully arguing the case for the US Government, said the government can kill American citizens without review in cases that trigger The State Secrets Act.

Not all members of the three-justice panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit agreed with the decision. Justice Patricia Millet asked Hinshelwood, “Do you appreciate how extraordinary that proposition is?” and then said the attorney was giving the government the power to “unilaterally decide to kill US citizens.”

Kareem, who works for the “On the Ground Network” news channel, alleged he is on a kill list that has made him a target for military attacks. The plaintiff alleged that since he is on the ground with rebel forces in Syria as part of his work as a journalist, his metadata from his electronic devices are accessible to the US military and allegedly triggering the attacks. Kareem also alleged he is on a kill list by the US Government.

The plaintiff’s work includes him being near Syrian rebel militants, who are linked to al-Qaida. Kareem’s lawsuit sought to remove him from the alleged kill list. However, in order to have Kareem removed from the alleged kill list, the US Government would have to confirm he was on the kill list in the first place and thus targeted.

The US Government requested the case be dismissed, invoking the State Secrets Privilege Act that was signed into law in 2013. The State Secrets Act offers wide liberties to the US Government, as “public disclosure of the information that the government seeks to protect would be reasonably likely to cause significant harm to the national defense or the diplomatic relations of the United States.”

Hinshelwood argued in court, in part, that because the journalist sought discovery in this case as to whether he was being targeted, it would make public the process the military uses to target him or others, and also would include information as to whether or not the United States had tried to murder Kareem, an American citizen.

The judge ruled in the US Government’s favor.

Kareem’s attorney, Tara J. Plochocki, said of the historic decision, “Whether it’s in a parking lot in the United States or abroad in Syria, the government has claimed—for the first time ever in this case—that it has the unfettered and unreviewable discretion to kill US citizens at will.”

However, as the law stands, the plaintiff’s rights cannot come before national security.

In the legal brief, the US Government states, “Even if plaintiff had plausibly alleged standing, the state secrets privilege forecloses litigation of his due process claim,” and “even the most compelling necessity cannot overcome the claim of privilege if the court is ultimately satisfied that military secrets are at stake,” United States v. Reynolds, 345 US 1, 11 (1954).

Currently, Kareem is being held against his will by radical Islamist group Hay’at Tahir al-Sham in Syria.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Diane Lilli
Diane Lilli is an award-winning Journalist, Editor, and Author with over 18 years of experience contributing to New Jersey news outlets, both in print and online. Notably, she played a pivotal role in launching the first daily digital newspaper, Jersey Tomato Press, in 2005. Her work has been featured in various newspapers, journals, magazines, and literary publications across the nation. Diane is the proud recipient of the Shirley Chisholm Journalism Award.

Related Articles

Crowd holds a sign displaying two portraits of Renee Good with the words “SAY HER NAME!” and “RENEE GOOD.”

Renee Good’s Family Sues U.S., ICE Agent and Trump Officials Under Ku Klux Klan-Era Law

The family of Renee Good has filed two federal lawsuits over her fatal shooting by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent in Minneapolis, including a civil rights case against ICE agent Jonathan Ross and senior Trump administration officials that invokes provisions of the Reconstruction-era Ku Klux Klan Act.The lawsuits, filed... Read More about Renee Good’s Family Sues U.S., ICE Agent and Trump Officials Under Ku Klux Klan-Era Law

President Donald Trump speaks at a podium in the White House briefing room as reporters and photographers watch.

DOJ Defends Trump’s White House Ban on CNN, Politico and MS NOW, Citing National Security

The Justice Department urged a federal judge to keep CNN, Politico and MS NOW reporters off White House grounds, arguing that President Donald Trump may restrict their access over national security concerns as the outlets fight to regain their press credentials.Government lawyers asked U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly on Tuesday... Read More about DOJ Defends Trump’s White House Ban on CNN, Politico and MS NOW, Citing National Security

U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota building in Minneapolis.

DOJ Uses Secretive “Alien Terrorist Removal Court” for the First Time

The Justice Department has carried out the first deportation ordered through a little-known federal court created three decades ago to remove noncitizens accused of terrorism using procedures that permit the government to rely on classified evidence.Nazira Haji Zada, a 47-year-old Afghan national and lawful permanent resident who had been living... Read More about DOJ Uses Secretive “Alien Terrorist Removal Court” for the First Time

Julian Assange standing near a window, looking out, with his reflection visible.

In a Public Nod to US Prisons as Inhumane, UK Court Rules WikiLeaks Founder Julian Assange Can Appeal Extradition to the US

In yet another twist in an almost decade-long espionage case against WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, 49, a UK court ruled he can appeal his extradition to the US. Assange’s attorneys successfully argued it would be harmful to his mental health to return to the US via extradition to face espionage... Read More about In a Public Nod to US Prisons as Inhumane, UK Court Rules WikiLeaks Founder Julian Assange Can Appeal Extradition to the US

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter