Skip to main content

Disney Asks Judge to Block FCC Review of ABC Licenses in First Amendment Fight

by Camila Curcio | Oct 06, 2026
Smartphone displaying the ABC logo in front of a Disney logo.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Disney asked a federal judge Tuesday to block the Federal Communications Commission from conducting an early review of eight ABC television licenses, arguing that the Trump administration is using the agency’s regulatory power to punish the network over programming and editorial decisions it dislikes.

The FCC urged U.S. District Judge Loren L. AliKhan to dismiss the case, arguing that the agency has yet to make a final decision on the licenses and that Disney brought its constitutional challenge before there was any agency action for the court to review.

AliKhan did not rule during the October 6, 2026, hearing in Washington. She questioned both sides over whether the court has authority to intervene now and whether the early license review itself is already causing the First Amendment harm Disney alleges. The judge requested additional written arguments before deciding how the case should proceed.

The dispute involves licenses for eight ABC-owned stations serving major markets including New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia and San Francisco. None would ordinarily come up for renewal before 2028, and several remain valid into 2030 or 2031.

The FCC nevertheless ordered ABC in April to submit early renewal applications as part of an investigation into whether Disney’s employment practices violated federal anti-discrimination requirements. Disney submitted the applications in May while continuing to contest the agency’s action.

Disney argues that the investigation cannot be separated from FCC Chairman Brendan Carr’s criticism of ABC programming and President Donald Trump’s public attacks on the network.

At Tuesday’s hearing, Disney attorney Beth Wilkinson argued that the government is attempting to censor and punish ABC for broadcasting material the administration disfavors. The company has asked AliKhan to stop the early renewal proceedings before the FCC determines whether to renew the stations’ licenses.

The government maintains that the review stems from an investigation that began before the early renewal order and from what the FCC has described as inadequate responses to requests for information about Disney’s employment practices. The agency says broadcasters operate under federal licenses and remain subject to statutory and public-interest obligations.

That leaves the court facing an important threshold question before it reaches the substance of Disney’s First Amendment allegations: whether Disney can sue now or must wait for the FCC to complete its proceedings.

The FCC argues that Disney is attempting to bypass the process Congress established for reviewing commission decisions. Under that framework, a final FCC licensing decision would ordinarily be challenged in a federal appeals court.

Disney says waiting would allow the alleged constitutional injury to continue while the agency subjects its stations to a process it claims was initiated in retaliation for protected speech.

The company has described the investigation itself as a burden on its editorial independence. Court filings say the FCC issued more than 600 requests concerning Disney’s employment practices, leading the company to produce more than 13,000 pages of documents.

Disney has also pointed to separate FCC scrutiny involving ABC programming, including The View and Jimmy Kimmel Live!, as evidence that the regulatory pressure reaches beyond employment issues.

The company says that pressure is already affecting programming decisions. According to its court filings, producers of The View have become more cautious about political guests and the use of candidate footage because of concerns about the commission’s actions.

The FCC disputes Disney’s characterization of the proceedings as retaliation. Carr has argued that requiring broadcasters to comply with federal law and their licensing obligations does not violate the First Amendment.

The early renewal procedure itself is unusual. At the hearing, AliKhan questioned the government about the basis for requiring Disney to seek renewal years ahead of schedule and noted the rarity of comparable proceedings.

The FCC’s own April order states that the agency may require early renewal when it considers the step necessary to conduct an investigation. The commission says its examination of Disney had already involved multiple rounds of document requests before the eight ABC licenses were called in early.

Disney sued the FCC in August, naming the commission and Carr as defendants. The company is represented by a legal team that includes former U.S. Solicitor General Paul Clement and trial lawyer Beth Wilkinson.

The case now turns first on whether AliKhan concludes that the district court can hear Disney’s challenge before the FCC takes final action. If the case survives the government’s request for dismissal, the court could then confront Disney’s broader claim that the early licensing review amounts to unconstitutional retaliation for ABC’s protected speech.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Get more Law Commentary in Google's Top Stories.

Camila Curcio
Camila studied Entertainment Journalism at UCLA and is the founder of a clothing brand inspired by music festivals and youth culture. Her YouTube channel, Cami's Playlist, focuses on concerts and music history. With experience in branding, marketing, and content creation, her work has taken her to festivals around the world, shaping her unique voice in digital media and fashion.

Related Articles

ABC logo above the entrance to the network’s building at 125.

Disney Accuses Trump FCC of Targeting ABC's Speech While Evading Court Review

Disney accused the Trump administration's Federal Communications Commission of using its power over ABC's broadcast licenses to punish the network for its programming, arguing in an October 12, 2026, court filing that the agency deliberately chose a regulatory process intended to pressure the company while avoiding immediate judicial review.The allegation... Read More about Disney Accuses Trump FCC of Targeting ABC's Speech While Evading Court Review

A hand holds a smartphone displaying the Voice of America logo against a U.S. flag.

Appeals Court Rules Kari Lake Illegally Fired Voice of America Director

A federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that Kari Lake and other Trump administration officials illegally fired Voice of America director Michael Abramowitz, upholding a permanent injunction that blocks his removal without approval from an independent oversight board.The unanimous November 10, 2026, decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the... Read More about Appeals Court Rules Kari Lake Illegally Fired Voice of America Director

Red CNN logo mounted on a wall above a tiled floor.

CNN, MS NOW and Politico Expand Lawsuit Against Trump Over White House Press Ban

CNN, MS NOW and Politico expanded their lawsuit against President Donald Trump on Wednesday, accusing the White House of continuing to exclude their journalists from presidential events despite a federal judge's order restoring their press credentials.In an amended complaint filed October 28, 2026, the three news organizations asked a federal... Read More about CNN, MS NOW and Politico Expand Lawsuit Against Trump Over White House Press Ban

Smartphone displaying apps for ABC News, CBS, NBC, CNN, Fox News, BBC, PBS, The CW, TNT and ESPN.

DOJ Investigates CNN, Fox News and Three Other Networks Over Trump Coverage Boycott

The Justice Department is investigating CNN, Fox News, ABC, CBS and NBC for possible antitrust violations after the five major television networks suspended shared coverage of President Donald Trump in protest of his administration's decision to ban three news organizations from the White House. Federal investigators are examining whether the... Read More about DOJ Investigates CNN, Fox News and Three Other Networks Over Trump Coverage Boycott

Close-up of a computer screen displaying a federal government job application webpage with an American flag icon and application text.

Judge Blocks Trump Administration’s “Loyalty Question” for Federal Job Applicants

A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from continuing to use an essay question that asked applicants for career federal jobs to explain how they would advance President Donald Trump’s policies and executive orders.U.S. District Judge George A. O’Toole Jr. in Boston issued a preliminary injunction Friday, September 11,... Read More about Judge Blocks Trump Administration’s “Loyalty Question” for Federal Job Applicants

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter