We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Utah prosecutors have refiled a first-degree felony rape charge against former Brigham Young University football player Parker Kingston, nearly five months after a judge dismissed the original case over trial delays. Hours after the new charge was filed on November 12, 2026, Kingston's attorneys asked a judge to remove the Washington County attorney and his entire office from the prosecution, alleging a conflict of interest.
Kingston, 22, is accused of sexually assaulting a woman at her apartment in St. George, Utah, in February 2025. He was initially arrested and charged in February 2026, but Fifth District Judge Jay Winward dismissed the case on June 18 after prosecutors requested additional time to prepare for trial.
The prosecution had sought to postpone Kingston's July trial because the woman who accused him was not emotionally prepared to testify. Winward denied the request, citing Kingston's constitutional right to a speedy trial, and dismissed the charge without prejudice, allowing prosecutors to bring the case again.
Washington County Attorney Jerry Jaeger said the decision to refile was made with the woman's support and based on the evidence gathered during the investigation. Her attorney, Andrew Deesing, welcomed the renewed prosecution, saying his client was grateful that the case would move forward.
According to the charging documents, Kingston and the woman had communicated through social media before arranging to meet at her apartment on February 23, 2025. Prosecutors allege she told Kingston before his arrival that she did not want him to visit solely for sex.
The two initially engaged in consensual sexual activity while watching a movie, according to the filing. The woman alleges Kingston later initiated intercourse despite her repeatedly telling him no. She reported the alleged assault to police four days later.
Kingston disputed her account during an interview with investigators, maintaining that she never refused intercourse. His attorneys have challenged the evidence presented by prosecutors and say he maintains his innocence.
Following the renewed charge, defense attorneys Cara Tangaro and Scott Williams filed a 35-page motion seeking to disqualify Jaeger and the Washington County Attorney's Office. They argue that Jaeger has developed a personal interest in defending his earlier handling of the investigation, creating a conflict with his responsibility to prosecute the case fairly.
Their allegations involve a disciplinary ComplaintA complaint is the formal pleading that generally begins a civil lawsuit. It identifies the parties, states the legal and factual basis for the plaintiff’s claims, explains why the court has authority to hear the case, and asks the court for a specific form of relief.Read more → Jaeger previously filed against two attorneys who publicly criticized the investigation on TikTok. The defense contends that statements Jaeger made in that complaint and other court filings conflict with evidence gathered in the case.
Kingston's attorneys argue that the prosecutor's interest in defending his previous statements could influence decisions about evidence, plea negotiations and whether to continue pursuing the charge.
Jaeger has maintained that his office thoroughly reviewed the case before filing the original charge. A spokesperson for the Washington County Attorney's Office said prosecutors would oppose the disqualification motion and address the defense's allegations in a court filing.
A judge has yet to decide whether Jaeger or his office must withdraw from the prosecution. Removing the county attorney would require another prosecutor to take responsibility for the case, but would not automatically dismiss the criminal charge.
The earlier dismissal also presents no automatic constitutional barrier to the renewed prosecution. Because the case ended before a jury was sworn or trial evidence was presented, Kingston had not been placed in jeopardy for purposes of the Fifth Amendment's double jeopardyDouble jeopardy is the constitutional protection that generally prevents a person from being prosecuted or punished more than once for the same criminal offense. The protection appears in the Fifth Amendment and applies to both federal and state prosecutions.Read more → Clause, which generally protects defendants from being tried twice for the same offense after jeopardy attaches.
Kingston, who played wide receiver for BYU, was removed from the football team and expelled from the university following his initial arrest. He is scheduled to appear in Fifth District Court in St. George on December 17, as the court considers the renewed prosecution and the defense's request to remove the county attorney.
Share This Article
If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.
Xiolene is a contributing journalist with more than a decade of experience in management, operations, and client service. Her background spans the veterinary and beauty industries, giving her experience working with businesses, consumers, employees, and service-focused organizations. Xiolene brings a practical business and consumer perspective to her coverage, focusing on making complex news and current events clear and accessible to readers.
A 24-year-old Stanford University student is facing trial on three felony sexual assault charges after returning to campus following a two-year suspension for sexually assaulting another student, according to the university's disciplinary findings.Leo Rossitter was charged in October 2024 with rape of an intoxicated person, oral copulation of an intoxicated...
Read
More about Stanford Student Faces Rape Trial After Returning From Suspension »
Child sexual abuse charges against The West Wing actor Timothy Busfield have been thrown out after a New Mexico judge found that prosecutors improperly blocked witnesses sought by grand jurors, undermining the proceedings that led to his indictment.State District Judge Joseph Montano dismissed the four-count indictment on October 16, 2026,...
Read
More about Timothy Busfield's Child Sex Abuse Charges Thrown Out After Judge Finds Prosecutorial Misconduct »
Kim Zolciak’s 15-year-old son, Kroy “KJ” Biermann Jr., has pleaded not guilty to seven felony charges in a sexual assault case in Georgia and is now asking a judge to move the prosecution from Superior Court to juvenile court.Attorney Jason Sheffield entered the plea Monday, October 5, 2026, on Biermann’s...
Read
More about Kim Zolciak’s Son KJ Biermann Pleads Not Guilty to 7 Felonies in Sexual Assault Case »
Former North Carolina State University sports medicine director Robert Michael Murphy Jr. has been indicted on 32 criminal charges accusing him of sexually abusing male student-athletes while providing medical treatment, adding a criminal prosecution to years of civil litigation over allegations involving the Wolfpack athletic program.A Wake County grand jury...
Read
More about Former NC State Sports Medicine Director Indicted on 32 Sex Abuse Charges as Civil Cases Continue »