Country singers Luke Bryan and Jason Aldean are asking a Tennessee judge to reject a landlord's attempt to hold them personally responsible for a $1.4 million judgment against their former Nashville restaurant, arguing that their lease guaranty limits their remaining liability to approximately $59,000.
Bryan, Aldean and former Major League Baseball player Adam LaRoche filed a motion in October 2026 seeking summary judgment in the dispute over E3 Chophouse, which closed in February. Their attorneys argue that the guaranty covered rent payments for only five years, leaving the three men responsible for certain construction costs after that period expired.
The landlord is seeking to collect a judgment entered against the restaurant's operating company, Outlaws LLC, after the business allegedly stopped paying rent and closed before its lease expired. The three men contend that their personal obligations were narrower than those of the restaurant itself.
The dispute began after GBT Realty pursued unpaid rent and other costs associated with the restaurant's closure. A Tennessee court subsequently entered a default judgment of $1,427,135.54 against Outlaws LLC, which has appealed that ruling.
Village 21 Investment Partners later sought to hold Bryan, Aldean and LaRoche personally liable under the lease guaranty they signed when E3 Chophouse opened its Nashville location in 2019.
Their attorneys maintain that the agreement imposed a five-year limit on responsibility for rent. Once that period expired, they argue, the guarantors remained liable only for the unpaid portion of the landlord's construction allowance.
According to their calculations, each man could owe no more than $19,585.60, bringing their combined potential liability to $58,756.80.
"The formula provided by the guaranty cap requires simple arithmetic," their attorneys wrote in the motion, arguing that the contract's language leaves no factual dispute requiring a trial.
A personal guaranty generally allows a landlord to seek payment from an individual when a business fails to meet its lease obligations. The extent of that responsibility depends on the agreement's terms, which are now central to the dispute.
The three men also challenge the landlord's calculation of damages, arguing that it failed to take reasonable steps to reduce its losses after the restaurant closed. The landlord's claims seek to recover substantially more than the guarantors say their agreement permits.
E3 Chophouse operated in Nashville after LaRoche, who established the restaurant brand in Colorado, partnered with Bryan and Aldean to open the location. The restaurant closed in February 2026, leaving the lease dispute unresolved.
A court hearing is scheduled for January 2027, when the judge is expected to consider whether the lease guaranty permits judgment without a trial. The ruling could determine whether Bryan, Aldean and LaRoche face liability for the full restaurant judgment or a substantially smaller amount.