We use cookies and similar technologies to help our website function, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. Some cookies are necessary for the website to operate, while others may be used for analytics or advertising.
Viewing as a visitor in
Legal News, Information & Blogs
NYC Horse Carriage Ban Challenged in Federal Court After Mamdani Signs Law
New York City's horse-drawn carriage industry is headed for a federal court battle after the union representing carriage drivers, stable workers and owners sued the city Thursday, November 19, 2026, minutes after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed a law banning the industry. The proposed class action seeks to overturn the legislation, arguing that it unlawfully strips workers and business owners of their livelihoods and valuable property without guaranteed compensation.
Filed in Manhattan federal court by the Transport Workers Union of America and TWU Local 100, the lawsuit also includes a carriage license owner and two drivers. The challenge targets Romanch's Law, which will end horse-drawn carriage operations throughout New York City on June 1, 2028, and asks the court to declare the ban unconstitutional and block its enforcement.
City-issued carriage licenses, commonly called medallions, represent substantial investments for owners who purchased them to operate their businesses. Eliminating those licenses, according to the complaint, destroys their economic value and violates protections under the U.S. and New York state constitutions. The legal challenge also questions the procedures used by the City Council to approve the measure.
TWU International President John Samuelsen criticized the law for eliminating licenses purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars while leaving compensation uncertain. He also objected to restrictions preventing owners from transferring their horses to carriage operators in other cities or states where the industry remains legal.
By April 1, 2027, city officials must submit a transition plan outlining employment assistance and considering compensation for carriage owners, including the value of their businesses, licenses and equipment. Any payments to owners remain subject to a future city decision.
Mamdani's administration has proposed assistance for approximately 200 workers through a new Horse Carriage Worker Industry Program. The initiative would provide job training, career counseling, educational opportunities and connections to employers, while city officials explore medallion buybacks and alternative tourism services, including electric carriages.
Existing licensing requirements, inspections and weather restrictions also figure prominently in the legal challenge. Citing testimony from city agency officials, the unions argue that these safeguards provide a way to address safety concerns while allowing carriage operations to continue.
According to the complaint, a Department of Consumer and Worker Protection official knew of no carriage licenses suspended or revoked in recent years. A Department of Health official also testified that carriage operations had been suspended 102 times over three years because of extreme temperatures, with inspectors reporting no violations of those suspensions.
Citing that enforcement record, the unions challenge the need to eliminate the industry rather than continue regulating its operations. They also question the urgency of a ban scheduled to take effect more than a year and a half after its enactment.
Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist, died June 17 after being thrown from a runaway carriage during a family visit to Central Park. His death prompted renewed efforts to end horse-drawn carriage rides, with lawmakers naming the legislation in his honor.
In a 40-7 vote on October 22, the City Council approved Romanch's Law, advancing the ban despite the union's warning that it would seek federal court InterventionIntervention is a court procedure that allows a person or organization that was not originally a party to a lawsuit to enter the case because the outcome could affect its interests or because it has a qualifying claim or defense connected to the dispute.Read more →. Council Speaker Julie Menin and Council Member Christopher Marte, the bill's sponsor, backed the measure over concerns about passenger safety and the welfare of horses working in crowded city streets.
During Thursday's signing ceremony, Mamdani defended the decision to end an industry that has operated in New York City for more than 150 years, saying changing conditions in Central Park require stronger protections for people and animals. Animal welfare advocates have long pushed for the ban, citing carriage accidents, traffic hazards, and concerns about the treatment of working horses.
Mamdani's administration has also pledged to help owners retire their horses through sanctuaries and rescue organizations. The law restricts the sale or transfer of carriage horses for slaughter or continued use in another horse-drawn carriage business.
Existing carriage licenses will expire May 31, 2028, although limited permits may remain available for weddings, parades, film productions and other special events.
New York City's Law Department has said it is reviewing the lawsuit. The union had previously announced plans to seek emergency court relief, potentially bringing the constitutionality of the ban before a federal judge well ahead of the 2028 deadline.
Share This Article
If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.
Alexandra Agraz is a managing consultant, former Diplomatic Aide, and guest contributor to Law Commentary. She has firsthand experience facilitating high-level international events, including the signing of significant economic and political agreements between the United States and Mexico. Her consulting expertise spans business strategy, organizational development, and cross-border initiatives. Her academic background includes business management studies at the bachelor's level and dual associate degrees in Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, and Film. Combining experience in diplomacy, business, and storytelling, she brings a multidisciplinary perspective to international affairs, legal developments, and cultural issues.
New York City's 168-year-old horse-drawn carriage industry is set to disappear after the City Council voted Thursday, October 22, to ban the longtime Central Park attraction following a tourist's death, setting up a potential federal court battle with a union fighting to preserve carriage jobs and businesses.The Council approved Romanch's...
Read
More about NYC Council Votes to Ban Central Park Horse Carriages as Union Threatens Lawsuit »
A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the Trump administration unlawfully withheld $73.5 million in highway funding from New York after the state refused to revoke nearly 33,000 commercial driver's licenses issued to noncitizens.The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled on November 13, 2026, that the Department...
Read
More about Appeals Court Blocks Trump's $73 Million Highway Funding Cut to New York »
Uber, Amazon and Instacart have sued New York City to block a law that would give delivery workers new protections when companies remove them from their apps, arguing the requirements violate the Constitution and interfere with existing contracts.The companies filed the lawsuit Wednesday, October 28, 2026, in Manhattan federal court,...
Read
More about Uber, Amazon and Instacart Sue NYC to Block Delivery Worker Law »
A New York appeals court has thrown out a homeowners' lawsuit challenging Mayor Zohran Mamdani's pied-Ã -terre tax rollout, overturning a judge's order that would have forced the city to redo thousands of tax notices and property assessments.A unanimous four-judge panel of the Appellate Division, Second Department, ruled Wednesday, November 4,...
Read
More about Appeals Court Throws Out Lawsuit Over Mamdani’s Second-Home Tax »
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and City Council Speaker Julie Menin have struck a deal to ban Central Park's horse-drawn carriages by June 2028, advancing legislation that could end the city's 168-year-old carriage industry after decades of failed attempts to shut it down.The agreement, announced October 13, 2026, advances...
Read
More about Mamdani and NYC Council Strike Deal to Ban Central Park Horse Carriages by 2028 »