Skip to main content

Supreme Court Agrees to Review Constitutionality of Bans on Gender-Affirming Care for Minors

by Nina Richards | Jun 24, 2024
A person holding a flag featuring the rainbow plus trans pride colors in front of the Supreme Court building.
Photo Source: Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images via Axios

On Monday (June 24), the Supreme Court agreed to hear the Biden Administration’s challenge to Tennessee’s controversial ban on gender-affirming care for transgender minors. The justices, expected to hear arguments close to the November presidential election, will deliberate on the constitutionality of these bans, with the potential to impact similar laws nationwide. This case will be the first time the Supreme Court substantively addresses the issue of gender-affirming care for minors.

The Tennessee law passed last year prohibits hormone therapy, puberty blockers, and surgeries intended for minors to transition to a gender different from their sex assigned at birth. Doctors who choose to administer such care are subjected to civil penalties. According to the Human Rights Campaign, this legislation is part of a broader trend, with almost half of the U.S. already implementing similar bans or restrictions on transgender care for minors.

Advocates, including the Biden administration and families of transgender minors, have challenged Tennessee's law, stating that the ban infringes upon the 14th Amendment by discriminating on the basis of sex. They contend that the law denies necessary medical treatment determined appropriate by families and doctors to address serious medical conditions such as gender dysphoria. They assert that such restrictions violate the rights guaranteed by the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the 14th Amendment, which safeguard against arbitrary state action and ensure equality under the law for all individuals.

Republican lawmakers, including Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti, argue that such decisions about gender-affirming care should be postponed until individuals reach adulthood. They maintain that the law protects minors from making irreversible decisions at a young age. Tennessee’s law specifically targets treatments that allow minors to identify with a gender different from their birth sex or to address discomfort from gender dysphoria.

Various advocacy groups and legal experts have weighed in on the significance of this case. Kelley Robinson, president of the Human Rights Campaign, stressed that all individuals deserve access to necessary medical care, including transgender and non-binary youth. An attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union of Tennessee (ACLU), Lucas Cameron-Vaughn, criticized the bans as political tools used to create division and emphasized the importance of medical decisions being made between families and doctors.

Conversely, former President Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican nominee, has expressed support for state efforts to ban gender-affirming care for minors. He has described such treatments as “child abuse” and has pledged to use federal power to block them if elected.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Nina Richards
Nina earned her Bachelor's Degree in Psychology from Brandman University, laying the foundation for her interest in and understanding of human behavior. She works full-time at Law Commentary and is dedicated to merging her passion for pop culture with legal insights. Combining her analytical skills and interest in staying updated on trends, she strives to deliver pop culture legal news, bridging the gap between law and contemporary society.

Related Articles

Gloved hand holding vials labeled estrogen and testosterone hormones.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Bid to Restrict Hormone Therapy for Transgender Federal Prisoners

The Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected the Trump administration’s request to immediately restore restrictions on gender-affirming care in federal prisons, leaving in place a lower-court order that protects access to hormone therapy and other accommodations while the case continues.The October 21, 2026, decision does not determine whether the Federal Bureau... Read More about Supreme Court Rejects Trump Bid to Restrict Hormone Therapy for Transgender Federal Prisoners

U.S. Supreme Court building under a cloudy sky.

Trump Asks Supreme Court to Allow Transgender Health Care Restrictions in Federal Prisons

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court on Monday to let federal prisons restrict hormone therapy and gender-affirming surgery for transgender inmates, seeking to enforce the policy after two lower courts refused to clear the way.The Justice Department filed an emergency request asking the justices to lift an injunction from... Read More about Trump Asks Supreme Court to Allow Transgender Health Care Restrictions in Federal Prisons

A transgender pride flag flies in front of the U.S. Supreme Court under a partly cloudy sky.

Trump Asks Supreme Court to Allow Transgender Troop Discharges Under Military Ban

The Trump administration is asking the Supreme Court to clear the way for the Pentagon to discharge transgender servicemembers who remain protected from its military ban, returning the policy to the justices after they allowed broader enforcement last year.Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed a petition Friday asking the Court... Read More about Trump Asks Supreme Court to Allow Transgender Troop Discharges Under Military Ban

A group of protesters holding a banner reading "TRANS KIDS ARE LOVED" alongside flags supporting LGBTQ+ rights.

Nine-Year-Old Transgender Boy Sues North Carolina Over New Bill Restricting Transgender Care

A nine-year-old transgender boy in North Carolina has filed a lawsuit against the state over a newly passed bill that puts limitations on gender-affirming care for individuals under the age of 18. The child is identified by the pseudonym Victor Voe, in the lawsuit to conceal his identity. The suit... Read More about Nine-Year-Old Transgender Boy Sues North Carolina Over New Bill Restricting Transgender Care

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter