Skip to main content

Trump Administration Sued Over Sanctions Against International Criminal Court

by Bridget Luckey | Aug 12, 2026
A United Nations flag flutters atop a flagpole in front of a modern glass office complex under a bright blue sky.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Four human rights organizations filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday challenging the Trump administration’s sanctions against the International Criminal Court, arguing President Donald Trump exceeded his emergency economic powers and violated constitutional protections for speech and due process.

The lawsuit, filed Aug. 11 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, was brought by Human Rights Watch, the American Friends Service Committee, the Center for Constitutional Rights and the Open Society Institute. The groups are challenging Trump’s 2025 executive order authorizing sanctions against certain ICC officials and others accused of supporting the court.

Executive Order 14203 allows the government to block property and restrict certain transactions involving people accused of supporting ICC actions against U.S. personnel or nationals of allied countries. The administration has since used the order to sanction ICC judges and prosecutors, U.N. human rights expert Francesca Albanese and three Palestinian rights organizations.

The groups claim the restrictions have forced them to limit research, legal advocacy, humanitarian work and contact with sanctioned people and organizations because violations can carry serious civil or criminal penalties. They argue the sanctions have affected more than financial transactions by interfering with activities that include legal representation, information sharing and collaboration.

A central part of the lawsuit challenges Trump’s use of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, known as IEEPA. The law gives presidents broad authority to restrict economic transactions after declaring a national emergency involving an unusual and extraordinary foreign threat to U.S. national security, foreign policy or the economy.

Congress has also placed limits on that authority, including protections involving certain communications and informational materials. The organizations argue Trump’s order goes beyond the emergency powers Congress granted and unlawfully reaches activities that should remain outside the government’s sanctions authority.

Their First Amendment claim focuses on the effect the policy has had on speech and association. A government rule does not have to directly ban a statement or publication to raise free speech concerns. Courts can also examine whether the threat of punishment causes people or organizations to stop engaging in constitutionally protected speech or advocacy.

A federal judge in the same district has already found a First Amendment problem with Executive Order 14203 in a separate case. In July 2025, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman ruled that the order violated the rights of two law professors who wanted to continue speech-based work involving the ICC and permanently barred federal officials from enforcing the challenged restrictions against them. The ruling applied only to those challengers and did not invalidate the executive order nationwide.

The new lawsuit also argues the sanctions are unconstitutionally vague under the Fifth Amendment. Due process generally requires laws carrying serious penalties to give people enough notice of what conduct is prohibited. The groups contend that language restricting the provision of “services” to sanctioned people does not clearly tell them whether activities including advocacy, legal work or information sharing could expose them to punishment.

The American Friends Service Committee raises a separate claim under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, a federal law that protects religious exercise from substantial government burdens unless the government can meet a demanding legal test. The Quaker organization argues the sanctions interfere with human rights and humanitarian work tied to its religious mission.

The administration imposed the sanctions amid its longstanding dispute with the ICC over the court’s authority. Trump’s executive order cites the court’s warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and says ICC actions involving the United States and Israel threaten U.S. sovereignty and national security. A White House official defended that position Tuesday, saying the court had infringed on the sovereignty of both countries.

The sanctions are part of a broader administration campaign against the court. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said last month that the United States would pressure ICC member countries to distance themselves from the institution, sanction organizations that work with the court and restrict travel by court staff.

Human Rights Watch and the other groups are asking the federal court to declare the challenged sanctions unlawful and block their enforcement, including additional designations under Executive Order 14203.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Bridget Luckey
Bridget studied Communications and Marketing at California State University, Long Beach. She also has experience in the live music events industry, which has allowed her to travel to festivals around the world. During this period, she acquired valuable expertise in branding, marketing, event planning, and public relations.

Related Articles

Red CNN logo mounted on a wall above a tiled floor.

CNN, MS NOW and Politico Expand Lawsuit Against Trump Over White House Press Ban

CNN, MS NOW and Politico expanded their lawsuit against President Donald Trump on Wednesday, accusing the White House of continuing to exclude their journalists from presidential events despite a federal judge's order restoring their press credentials.In an amended complaint filed October 28, 2026, the three news organizations asked a federal... Read More about CNN, MS NOW and Politico Expand Lawsuit Against Trump Over White House Press Ban

International Criminal Court building in The Hague with the court’s blue sign in the foreground.

Trump Hits International Criminal Court With Sweeping Sanctions Hours After Former Judge Wins Nobel Peace Prize

The Trump administration imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Court (ICC) on October 9, 2026, targeting the entire institution just hours after one of its former judges won the Nobel Peace Prize. The move threatens the world's permanent war crimes tribunal with restrictions on U.S. financial services, technology, and... Read More about Trump Hits International Criminal Court With Sweeping Sanctions Hours After Former Judge Wins Nobel Peace Prize

Protesters sit on city steps holding signs reading “ICE OUT OF NYC” during an immigration demonstration.

Federal Judge Throws Out Trump's Bid to Overturn NYC Sanctuary Laws

A federal judge has thrown out the Trump administration's lawsuit against New York City's sanctuary laws, rejecting its attempt to force local authorities to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. The October 15, 2026, ruling preserves city restrictions on assisting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).U.S. District Judge Ramón E. Reyes... Read More about Federal Judge Throws Out Trump's Bid to Overturn NYC Sanctuary Laws

Donald Trump walks across a lawn wearing a dark suit and red tie.

Appeals Court Leaves Trump Sanctions in Place Over ‘Collusive’ $10 Billion IRS Lawsuit

A federal appeals court has refused to block sanctions against President Donald Trump and his lawyers over a judge’s finding that his $10 billion lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service was improperly used to secure benefits through a settlement with his own administration.A three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit... Read More about Appeals Court Leaves Trump Sanctions in Place Over ‘Collusive’ $10 Billion IRS Lawsuit

Palestinian flag with a raised fist emblem and the word PALESTINE visible, waving at an outdoor protest.

Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration Cannot Deport International Students for Pro-Palestinian Speech

A federal judge in California has ruled that the Trump administration cannot use federal immigration law to revoke visas or pursue deportation against international students because they expressed pro-Palestinian views, criticized Israel or engaged in other political speech protected by the First Amendment.U.S. District Judge Noël Wise issued the 90-page... Read More about Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration Cannot Deport International Students for Pro-Palestinian Speech

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter