Skip to main content

Juror Misconduct

Juror misconduct refers to conduct by a juror that violates court instructions, threatens impartiality or interferes with the jury’s ability to decide a case based solely on the evidence and law presented in court.

Examples can include independently researching the case, communicating with parties or witnesses, discussing the case before deliberations are permitted, concealing material information during jury selection or considering information that was never admitted into evidence.

Misconduct can also involve a juror’s refusal to follow the court’s legal instructions. Courts distinguish that situation from a juror who simply disagrees with the other members of the jury about the evidence or the proper verdict.

Judges must proceed carefully when allegations of misconduct arise during deliberations. Jury deliberations receive strong protection from outside interference, and courts generally avoid questioning jurors about their reasoning or attempting to influence how they vote.

A judge may conduct a limited inquiry when credible evidence suggests that a juror is unable or unwilling to perform the required duties. Depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances, the court may remove a juror, replace the juror with an alternate, give additional instructions or declare a MistrialThe termination of a trial before a final verdict because a problem prevents the proceeding from being completed fairly or lawfully.Read more →.

Not every irregularity requires a new trial. Courts usually examine whether misconduct occurred and whether it created a sufficient risk of prejudice to undermine the fairness of the proceeding.

Share This Term

Lindsay Clancy sits facing the camera in a gray sweater.

Can Lindsay Clancy Be Tried Again? Massachusetts High Court Takes Up Double Jeopardy Fight

Massachusetts’ highest court has agreed to decide whether Lindsay Clancy can be tried a second time for the deaths of her three children after her first murder trial ended with an 11-1 jury deadlock and allegations that the lone holdout juror was refusing to follow the judge’s instructions on reasonable... Read More about Can Lindsay Clancy Be Tried Again? Massachusetts High Court Takes Up Double Jeopardy Fight

Close-up of clear plastic evidence tubes and a document labeled EVIDENCE on a lab bench.

Colorado DNA Analyst Gets 10 Years for Manipulating Evidence in Hundreds of Cases

A former Colorado DNA analyst was sentenced to 10 years in prison Tuesday for manipulating forensic evidence, misconduct that has forced authorities to review more than 1,000 criminal cases and has already reached the Colorado Supreme Court.Yvonne “Missy” Woods, 66, spent nearly three decades as a forensic scientist with the... Read More about Colorado DNA Analyst Gets 10 Years for Manipulating Evidence in Hundreds of Cases

A house-like building engulfed in flames with thick smoke rising, surrounded by trees, and a street sign reading 1267 to 1337 Palisades Drive in the foreground.

Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlock, Retrial Set for Oct. 19

A federal judge declared a mistrial Friday in the arson case against Jonathan Rinderknecht and set an Oct. 19 retrial after jurors deadlocked over whether prosecutors proved he started a New Year’s fire that later became the deadly Palisades Fire in Los Angeles.U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang ordered Rinderknecht held... Read More about Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlock, Retrial Set for Oct. 19

A view of an empty courtroom, highlighting the judge's bench and seating.

“Non-Prejudicial Misconduct” Found When Jurors Sent a Note to Judge That Urged Leniency for Man Convicted of Murder

Late one night in March 2020, Omar Herrera, 19, and a 17-year-old juvenile friend, identified as A.M., approached Manuel Sac Ajtzalam and a prostitute in the Mission District of San Francisco. Intending to rob them, the defendants got into an argument where punches were exchanged. Herrera was found guilty of... Read More about “Non-Prejudicial Misconduct” Found When Jurors Sent a Note to Judge That Urged Leniency for Man Convicted of Murder

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter