Skip to main content

Mistrial

A mistrial occurs when a court ends a trial before the jury returns a final verdict or, in a bench trial, before the judge reaches a final decision.

Mistrials can arise for many reasons. A jury may be unable to reach a unanimous verdict, a juror may become unable to continue serving, inadmissible evidence may improperly reach the jury, serious misconduct may occur or another event may make it impossible to complete the proceeding fairly.

Either side may request a mistrial, or a judge may declare one without a request.

The consequences depend heavily on why the trial ended. When a defendant asks for or agrees to a mistrial, prosecutors can usually retry the case. If a judge declares a mistrial over the defendant’s objection, the Double JeopardyDouble jeopardy is the constitutional protection that generally prevents a person from being prosecuted or punished more than once for the same criminal offense. The protection appears in the Fifth Amendment and applies to both federal and state prosecutions.Read more → Clause generally requires a showing of Manifest NecessityA legal standard requiring a strong justification for ending a criminal trial over the defendant’s objection before a verdict is reached.Read more → before a second trial can proceed.

A hung jury is the classic situation in which courts allow retrial after a mistrial. Other circumstances receive closer scrutiny because a criminal defendant has a constitutional interest in having the original jury complete the case.

A mistrial is not the same as an acquittal. A mistrial ordinarily leaves the criminal charges unresolved, while an acquittal generally prevents the government from prosecuting the defendant again for the same offense.

Procedures for declaring a mistrial and determining whether a retrial is permitted vary among jurisdictions.

Share This Term

Lindsay Clancy sits in court, shown in profile with long brown hair and a beige sweater.

Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

A Massachusetts judge has rejected Lindsay Clancy's attempt to dismiss three murder charges in the deaths of her young children, allowing prosecutors to pursue a second trial after a September mistrial. Her attorneys plan to challenge the decision before the state's highest court.Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan ruled on... Read More about Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

Lindsay Clancy sits in a courtroom, shown in profile with long brown hair and wearing a beige sweater.

Lindsay Clancy Seeks to Block Murder Retrial on Double Jeopardy Grounds

Lindsay Clancy’s attorneys are asking a Massachusetts judge to dismiss the murder charges against her, arguing that the September 4 mistrial violated constitutional protections against double jeopardy because the court ended deliberations without sufficiently examining concerns about the lone holdout juror.Attorneys Martin Weinberg and Kevin Reddington filed the motion Monday... Read More about Lindsay Clancy Seeks to Block Murder Retrial on Double Jeopardy Grounds

Lindsay Clancy sits in a courtroom in profile with long dark hair and a light-blue top, during her murder trial.

Why Lindsay Clancy’s Trial Ended in a Mistrial Even After 11 Jurors Reportedly Favored Acquittal

The murder trial of Lindsay Clancy ended without a verdict after seven days of deliberations, even though three jurors now say 11 members of the panel believed she should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.For families and observers who followed the case closely, that outcome can feel difficult... Read More about Why Lindsay Clancy’s Trial Ended in a Mistrial Even After 11 Jurors Reportedly Favored Acquittal

Kevin Reddington, Lindsay Clancy’s defense attorney, stands at a courtroom bench as Clancy sits nearby during a session.

Lindsay Clancy’s Lawyer Asked Trump for a Pardon He Had No Power to Grant

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer asked President Donald Trump to pardon her after her Massachusetts murder trial ended in a mistrial, even though presidential pardon power does not extend to the state murder charges against her.Attorney Kevin Reddington made the appeal Tuesday on ABC’s “Good Morning America,” asking Trump to consider... Read More about Lindsay Clancy’s Lawyer Asked Trump for a Pardon He Had No Power to Grant

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter