Skip to main content

Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity

Not guilty by reason of insanity is a criminal verdict available in jurisdictions that recognize an insanity defense when a defendant committed the charged conduct but lacked the mental capacity required for criminal responsibility under the governing legal test.

The terminology and legal standards vary significantly among jurisdictions. Some states use terms such as not guilty by reason of insanity, not criminally responsible, or lack of criminal responsibility. A small number of states have substantially restricted or eliminated a traditional insanity defense.

An insanity defense is different from simply showing that a defendant had a mental illness. The legal question is whether the defendant’s condition satisfied the jurisdiction’s specific test at the time of the offense.

Some jurisdictions focus on whether the defendant understood the nature or wrongfulness of the conduct. Others also consider whether a qualifying mental disorder substantially impaired the ability to conform conduct to the law.

The defense is also distinct from competency to stand trial. Competency concerns whether a defendant presently understands the proceedings and can assist counsel. An insanity defense concerns the defendant’s mental condition when the alleged crime occurred.

A verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity does not necessarily result in immediate release. Defendants are frequently committed to a psychiatric facility and may remain subject to court supervision until they no longer satisfy the legal requirements for confinement.

Rules governing who bears the burden of proving insanity and the level of proof required differ among federal and state courts.

Share This Term

Lindsay Clancy sits in a courtroom in profile with long dark hair and a light-blue top, during her murder trial.

Why Lindsay Clancy’s Trial Ended in a Mistrial Even After 11 Jurors Reportedly Favored Acquittal

The murder trial of Lindsay Clancy ended without a verdict after seven days of deliberations, even though three jurors now say 11 members of the panel believed she should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.For families and observers who followed the case closely, that outcome can feel difficult... Read More about Why Lindsay Clancy’s Trial Ended in a Mistrial Even After 11 Jurors Reportedly Favored Acquittal

Jury members seated in a courtroom during a trial.

Constitution Requires Jury Instruction on Imperfect Self-Defense for Defendant With Good-Faith Belief in Need for Lethal Force

Jason Carl Schuller was accused of the first-degree murder of his friend W.T. At his trial, Schuller pled not guilty by reason of insanity. Evidence, including testimony by a neighbor, showed W.T. had received nine gunshot wounds to his head as well as serious burn injuries. The jury heard evidence... Read More about Constitution Requires Jury Instruction on Imperfect Self-Defense for Defendant With Good-Faith Belief in Need for Lethal Force

Mugshot of a man with short hair and a beard, looking directly at the camera.

Murder Conviction Affirmed When Appeals Court Found Lack of Instruction on Lesser Offense Was Harmless Error

Even though the trial judge failed to instruct jurors that a claim of imperfect self-defense was possible, an appeals court ruled that the omission was harmless error as it upheld the first-degree murder conviction of a stoned defendant who shot his friend in the head nine times, then set him... Read More about Murder Conviction Affirmed When Appeals Court Found Lack of Instruction on Lesser Offense Was Harmless Error

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter