Supreme Court Blocks Florida Law Criminalizing Undocumented Border Crossings

by Lawrence J. Tjan | Jul 09, 2025
A police officer stands guard outside the U.S. Supreme Court building, which is covered in scaffolding. Photo Source: AP Photo/Mariam Zuhaib via AP News

The U.S. Supreme Court has blocked enforcement of a key provision of a controversial Florida law that criminalized entry into the state by undocumented immigrants, delivering a setback to Governor Ron DeSantis's immigration policy.

In a succinct, one-sentence order issued Wednesday, the high court upheld a lower court's ruling without elaboration or recorded dissents. The provision in question had imposed mandatory prison sentences for undocumented individuals crossing state lines into Florida.

The dispute stems from a law enacted by Governor DeSantis in February, which quickly garnered national attention following an incident in April involving Juan Carlos Lopez-Garcia, a U.S.-born citizen arrested by Florida Highway Patrol while crossing from Georgia. Lopez-Garcia, wrongly detained for 24 hours, became a central figure highlighting concerns raised by immigration advocacy groups.

The plaintiffs, including immigrant rights organizations, argued that the Florida statute directly conflicted with established federal immigration law. They contended that under longstanding Supreme Court precedent, immigration regulation is a federal domain, preempting any conflicting state laws.

Florida officials defended the measure as necessary to mitigate what they termed the "evil effects of immigration," asserting that state law complemented, rather than contradicted, federal immigration statutes.

Nevertheless, the Supreme Court has consistently ruled that federal law supersedes state laws in immigration matters. Similar statutes criminalizing immigration at the state level have been previously blocked by federal courts in Oklahoma, Iowa, and Idaho, with courts repeatedly affirming that such state measures infringe upon the federal government's exclusive authority to regulate immigration.

Most recently, in 2024, the conservative Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals halted a similar Texas law, underscoring the ongoing judicial consensus against state-level immigration enforcement.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Lawrence J. Tjan
Lawrence J. Tjan
Lawrence is an attorney with experience in corporate and general business law, complemented by a background in law practice management. His litigation expertise spans complex issues such as antitrust, bad faith, and medical malpractice. On the transactional side, Lawrence has handled buy-sell agreements, Reg D disclosures, and stock option plans, bringing a practical and informed approach to each matter. Lawrence is the founder and CEO of Law Commentary.

Related Articles

Seal of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals displayed on a stone surface.
Federal Appeals Court Blocks Iowa Law Targeting Undocumented Immigrants

A U.S. appeals court on Friday upheld a decision blocking Iowa from implementing a law that would have allowed for the arrest and prosecution of undocumented immigrants, citing federal supremacy over immigration enforcement. The St. Louis-based 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Iowa’s law, which criminalized “illegal reentry”... Read More »

The Supreme Court building at sunset.
Supreme Court Clears Texas to Enforce Controversial Immigration Law

The Supreme Court, on Tuesday (May 14), allowed Texas to immediately begin enforcing a controversial immigration law, Senate Bill 4 (S.B. 4), which permits state officials to arrest and detain individuals suspected of entering the country illegally. This decision represents a temporary victory for Texas in its ongoing battle with... Read More »

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis speaking at a press conference about Senate Bill 1808, which mandates law enforcement to collaborate with ICE on immigration enforcement.
Florida Gov DeSantis Mandates Law Enforcement to Work with ICE

On Friday, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed into law Senate Bill 1808 to further crackdown on illegal immigration in the state. The new law mandates law enforcement agencies that oversee detention facilities to work with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). At the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office during an event named... Read More »