Skip to main content

Manifest Necessity

Manifest necessity is the constitutional standard courts use to determine whether a criminal defendant can be retried after a judge declares a MistrialThe termination of a trial before a final verdict because a problem prevents the proceeding from being completed fairly or lawfully.Read more → over the defendant’s objection.

The doctrine comes from the Double JeopardyDouble jeopardy is the constitutional protection that generally prevents a person from being prosecuted or punished more than once for the same criminal offense. The protection appears in the Fifth Amendment and applies to both federal and state prosecutions.Read more → Clause. Once jeopardy has attached, a defendant has an interest in having the original jury decide the case. A judge therefore cannot end the trial simply because restarting it would be more convenient.

The U.S. Supreme Court first articulated the doctrine in United States v. Perez in 1824. The Court held that a retrial can proceed when there is a “manifest necessity” for the mistrial or when ending the trial serves the ends of public justice.

A genuinely deadlocked jury is the clearest example. If jurors cannot agree on a verdict after reasonable deliberations, a judge usually has discretion to declare a mistrial and allow prosecutors to retry the defendant.

Other situations receive closer review. Courts may examine whether the judge considered reasonable alternatives, whether the problem could have been corrected without ending the trial and whether the defendant objected.

Manifest necessity does not require that a mistrial be literally unavoidable in every circumstance. The amount of deference given to the trial judge depends on the reason for ending the case. Decisions involving a genuinely hung jury generally receive substantial deference, while mistrials caused by avoidable legal or procedural problems can receive more exacting scrutiny.

If an appellate court finds that no manifest necessity existed, the Double Jeopardy Clause may prevent the government from trying the defendant again.

Share This Term

Lindsay Clancy sits in court, shown in profile with long brown hair and a beige sweater.

Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

A Massachusetts judge has rejected Lindsay Clancy's attempt to dismiss three murder charges in the deaths of her young children, allowing prosecutors to pursue a second trial after a September mistrial. Her attorneys plan to challenge the decision before the state's highest court.Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan ruled on... Read More about Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial After Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Murder Charges

Lindsay Clancy sits in a courtroom, shown in profile with long brown hair and wearing a beige sweater.

Lindsay Clancy Seeks to Block Murder Retrial on Double Jeopardy Grounds

Lindsay Clancy’s attorneys are asking a Massachusetts judge to dismiss the murder charges against her, arguing that the September 4 mistrial violated constitutional protections against double jeopardy because the court ended deliberations without sufficiently examining concerns about the lone holdout juror.Attorneys Martin Weinberg and Kevin Reddington filed the motion Monday... Read More about Lindsay Clancy Seeks to Block Murder Retrial on Double Jeopardy Grounds

A house-like building engulfed in flames with thick smoke rising, surrounded by trees, and a street sign reading 1267 to 1337 Palisades Drive in the foreground.

Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlock, Retrial Set for Oct. 19

A federal judge declared a mistrial Friday in the arson case against Jonathan Rinderknecht and set an Oct. 19 retrial after jurors deadlocked over whether prosecutors proved he started a New Year’s fire that later became the deadly Palisades Fire in Los Angeles.U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang ordered Rinderknecht held... Read More about Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlock, Retrial Set for Oct. 19

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Topics

Subscribe to Newsletter