Skip to main content

Supreme Court Weighs Immigration Travel Ban

by Alan Barlow | May 17, 2018
A shadow of scales of justice cast on a wall painted with the American flag, with barbed wire along the top.
Photo Source: Adobe Stock Image

Is it a travel ban? Is it a Muslim ban? Is it a valid exercise of presidential authority? The Supreme Court has heard oral arguments in Trump v. Hawaii, the case challenging the constitutionality of President Trump’s Executive Order halting immigration from six predominately Muslim countries. The order is in effect while the court deliberates, and while the court deliberates, the rest of the country argues over whether the order is anti-Muslim or anti-terrorism, and people seeking to immigrate or already temporarily in the U.S. remain uncertain about their prospects for the future.

President Trump signed Executive Order 13769, titled Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States, on January 27, 2017. Within two days, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) had obtained a temporary injunction from a federal court blocking certain consequences of the order. A federal court in Washington halted the order nationwide on March 3rd, and the President signed a modified version on March 6th. This order was blocked by a federal judge in Hawaii nine days later. The United States Supreme Court agreed to take up the case in June and allowed a portion of the order to go into effect while the case was pending.

On September 24th, President Trump signed a third version of the travel ban. This latest version limits immigration from six predominately Muslim countries in the middle east: Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria, Sudan and Yemen. Also restricted are immigrants from North Korea (who weren’t exactly flooding our borders anyway) as well as certain groups of people from Venezuela. The ban prevents people from the listed countries from emigrating permanently to the US and also halts temporary stays for tourism, work or study, depending on the country.

This latest version of the travel ban became the subject of the Supreme Court’s April 25th oral argument hearing in the case of Trump v. Hawaii. Lower courts had determined that the various versions of the ban were unlawful nationality-based discrimination. It remains to be seen how the high court will rule, but based on the tone of questioning from the bench, it seems that the justices may be willing to give the president the benefit of the doubt that this is not a Muslim ban, despite his campaign rhetoric and Tweets to the contrary.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Alan Barlow
Alan Barlow, a licensed attorney in Oklahoma and California, is a versatile writer and editor who specializes in legal topics across various practice areas throughout the United States. With a Bachelor's degree in Journalism/Professional Writing and a juris doctor degree from the University of Oklahoma, he brings a unique blend of legal expertise and communication skills to his work. Alan is a senior editor for Law Commentary.

Related Articles

Protesters hold a “Release Mahmoud Khalil” sign featuring his portrait outside Columbia University.

Mahmoud Khalil Asks Supreme Court to Overturn Ruling That Could Put Him Back in ICE Custody

Mahmoud Khalil, the former Columbia University graduate student who spent 104 days in immigration detention over his pro-Palestinian activism, asked the U.S. Supreme Court on October 19, 2026, to overturn a ruling that could send him back into ICE custody as the Trump administration pursues his deportation.Khalil, a lawful permanent... Read More about Mahmoud Khalil Asks Supreme Court to Overturn Ruling That Could Put Him Back in ICE Custody

The U.S. Supreme Court building viewed from below against a partly cloudy sky.

Supreme Court Clears Trump to Resume Third-Country Deportations as Justices Take Up Legal Fight

The Supreme Court on Tuesday cleared the Trump administration to resume deporting migrants to countries other than their own while the justices prepare to decide whether the policy violates federal law and constitutional due process protections.The unsigned September 29 order puts on hold a federal court judgment that required migrants... Read More about Supreme Court Clears Trump to Resume Third-Country Deportations as Justices Take Up Legal Fight

Donald Trump speaks at a podium with a microphone during a formal event.

Trump Administration Pauses Immigrant Visa Appointments Worldwide Days After 75-Country Ban Struck Down

The Trump administration has paused immigrant visa appointments at U.S. embassies and consulates worldwide, days after a federal judge struck down a separate policy that blocked immigrant visas for nationals of 75 countries.The State Department says the scheduling changes are temporary and needed to train consular officers on how to... Read More about Trump Administration Pauses Immigrant Visa Appointments Worldwide Days After 75-Country Ban Struck Down

Donald J. Trump sits at a desk in the Oval Office, holding up an open, signed document.

Trump’s New Birthright Citizenship Order Stays in Place as Judge Questions Constitutionality

President Donald Trump’s new order restricting birthright citizenship remained in effect Friday after a federal judge declined to immediately block it, while raising questions about whether the president can create new citizenship exceptions following a recent Supreme Court ruling.U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman in Maryland denied immigrant-rights advocates’ request for... Read More about Trump’s New Birthright Citizenship Order Stays in Place as Judge Questions Constitutionality

Legal term

Search articles and Legalpedia

Subscribe to Newsletter